forums

BREAKING - Joe Judge to the Giants as HC

Advertisement
nystateofmind said:
People on here didn’t think he was good enough for Mississippi State.

Goes to show how much they know.
Click to expand...


Some coaches aren't good enough for a particular university. Some coaches are too good for a particular university.

I would imagine you will grade this coaching hire as a C.
 
Advertisement
As an Eagles fan, I love this hire. Plus possibly keeping Jason Garrett in the NFC East as offensive coordinator. Cool!!!
 
It's telling that none of these mega-NFL franchises like Dallas and NY even offered Nick Saban or Urban Meyer.

Goes to show that if you remove recruiting from the equation, these are just average coaches.
 
RightSaidFred said:
It's telling that none of these mega-NFL franchises like Dallas and NY even offered Nick Saban or Urban Meyer.

Goes to show that if you remove recruiting from the equation, these are just average coaches.
Click to expand...
Saban would never take an NFL job.

Meyer might, but it would have to be the perfect situation.
 
nystateofmind said:
Saban would never take an NFL job.

Meyer might, but it would have to be the perfect situation.
Click to expand...

Meyer was begging for the Dallas job.

I'm sure Saban would have taken either the Giants or the Cowboys job if offered. Both are far more prestigious than University of Alabama. Unless he's just old and riding the wave toward retirement.

But any coach with any ambition at all would take those prime NFL jobs over any college gig.
 
Advertisement
RightSaidFred said:
Meyer was begging for the Dallas job.

I'm sure Saban would have taken either the Giants or the Cowboys job if offered. Both are far more prestigious than University of Alabama. Unless he's just old and riding the wave toward retirement.

But any coach with any ambition at all would take those prime NFL jobs over any college gig.
Click to expand...
Nick failed badly at Miami. I don't think his pride will allow him to take that risk again while he is now viewed by many as the goat in college
 
BoxingRobes said:
You're giving Jones a lot of credit...he's not going to be that good.
Click to expand...

No kidding. Subpar arm. Turnover prone. Never above 6.8 YPA in 4 seasons as a starter...college and pro.

He was a rightfully a lower pick who was shoved into the high first round. Now he looks decent at times only because the NFL defensive realities and rules realities don't automatically dismantle a quarterback of that caliber.

The NFC East is fully earning its mediocre reputation of late. Carson Wentz was tunnel vision this season and flopped to 6.7 YPA. He has very little change of pace on key throws instead of mindlessly gunning it. Dwayne Haskins was a one-year guy with very little athletic ability who like Jones shoved into the first round.

Are the head coaches in that division really going to pin their futures on those guys? I could somewhat understand it with Wentz because he has a good TD to INT rate and that one excellent second season with 8.3 Adjusted Yards Per Attempt and 11-2 won/loss record. Wentz is eligible to relax and start to see the field. But Ron Rivera aligning with Dwayne Haskins reminds me of Butch Davis being stupid enough to stake his NFL career on Tim Couch, a guy with a crank up delivery and noodle arm.

Daniel Jones looks like a very poor man's Matt Ryan.
 
Awsi Dooger said:
No kidding. Subpar arm. Turnover prone. Never above 6.8 YPA in 4 seasons as a starter...college and pro.

He was a rightfully a lower pick who was shoved into the high first round. Now he looks decent at times only because the NFL defensive realities and rules realities don't automatically dismantle a quarterback of that caliber.

The NFC East is fully earning its mediocre reputation of late. Carson Wentz was tunnel vision this season and flopped to 6.7 YPA. He has very little change of pace on key throws instead of mindlessly gunning it. Dwayne Haskins was a one-year guy with very little athletic ability who like Jones shoved into the first round.

Are the head coaches in that division really going to pin their futures on those guys? I could somewhat understand it with Wentz because he has a good TD to INT rate and that one excellent second season with 8.3 Adjusted Yards Per Attempt and 11-2 won/loss record. Wentz is eligible to relax and start to see the field. But Ron Rivera aligning with Dwayne Haskins reminds me of Butch Davis being stupid enough to stake his NFL career on Tim Couch, a guy with a crank up delivery and noodle arm.

Daniel Jones looks like a very poor man's Matt Ryan.
Click to expand...
U wilding Daniel is pretty good
 
Back
Top