forums

Best Player at each position while at the U

HarryCarayisGoat

HarryCarayisGoat

Senior
Banned
Joined
Nov 2, 2011
Messages
5,204
QB- Toretta
RB- McGahee
WR- Moss
TE- Winslow
OL- McKinnie
DL- Sapp
LB- Ray Lewis
DB- Rolle
S- Reed
K- Huerta
P- Bosher

Who ya got?
 
Advertisement
Toretta? really? no way, not in my book- I go with Kosar or Walsh or Testeverde,.,or even kelly, dorsey or erickson over toretta, but that's just me.
 
Qb- Dorsey
Rb- portis
Wr- johnson
Te- Winslow
Ol- mckinne
Dl- sapp
Lb- vilma
Cb- rolle
S- Taylor
Kr/pr - Hester
 
Qb Dorsey
Rb Duke (played for the worst coach and broke numbers.)
Wr Moss
Ol mckinnie
Dl Sapp
Lb Lewis
DB Reed/Taylor
K/P Bosher
 
EJ at RB. Different league than Willis IMO. Other positions are so tough because we have had so many good ones.
 
QB - Dorsey
RB - McGahee
TE - Shockey
WR - Irvin
OL - Mckinnie/Searcy
DL - Sapp/Stubbs
LB - Dan Morgan
CB - Ryan Mcneil
S - Taylor
 
Advertisement
Qb Kelly
Rb James
Wr Irvin
Wr Moss
Te Shockey
Slot/Sb Bratton
Lt Mckinnie
RT Searcy
Lb Morgan/ Lewis/ Armstead
S Taylor/ Reed
Dt Brown/ Sapp
DL Hendricks/ Kennedy
Cb Starks/ Rolle
I
 
I always take a players entire career into account

Qb. Jim Kelly
Rb. Edge James
Ol. Jim Otto
Wr. Reggie Wayne
Te shockey
Dl. Kennedy/ sapp
De hendricks
Lb. Lewis
Cb. McNeil
S. Reed
Rs. Hester
Coach. Jj
 
Last edited:
PAR said:
I always take a players entire career into account

Qb. Jim Kelly
Rb. Edge James
Ol. Jim Otto
Wr. Reggie Wayne
Te shockey
Dl. Kennedy/ sapp
De hendricks
Lb. Lewis
Cb. McNeil
S. Reed
Rs. Hester
Coach. Jj
Click to expand...

Not bad, Otto and Hendricks were absolute beasts.
 
dannymac___ said:
FRCane said:
QB - Dorsey
RB - McGahee
TE - Shockey
WR - Irvin
OL - Mckinnie/Searcy
DL - Sapp/Stubbs
LB - Dan Morgan
CB - Ryan Mcneil
S - Taylor
Click to expand...

Good list but 1. add Duke and cross out McGahee.
Click to expand...

Rotflmfao at Duke over mcgahee
McGahee backed up Portis one season and started one season
1687 yards 27 TDs in one year
Duke started three years. 26 TDs. Total.
Methinks if McGahee was on roster w Dallas Crawford and Eduardo Clements he might've played more than one season

/strike Irvin and add Hurns hahahahaha (Hurns is the goods but come on mane)
 
Last edited:
HarryCarayisGoat said:
rccollins said:
Toretta? really? no way, not in my book- I go with Kosar or Walsh or Testeverde,.,or even kelly, dorsey or erickson over toretta, but that's just me.
Click to expand...

Love all those mother ****ers. But Toretta and them boys were sick.
Click to expand...

NC AND Heisman -- got to go with Toretta. Steve and Ken were both a cheat call by ref from back to back undefeated NC seasons, but no Heisman. Really as QB, Kelly was probably the best but this is THE U and no hardware. Then Testeverde ... ah ****, they were all just go frigging good.
 
Advertisement
We have had some many greats at so many positions that it is about impossible to pick the best. The exception is probably DE or DL as whole. That would have to be The Mad Stork, with no disrespect to Stubbs and all those great DTs. Ted was in a league of his own, even into the NFL. He was the only player The Greek gave one point to whatever team he played on; he was that good. Three time All American and fifth in Heisman when Miami was SunTan U.
 
QB- Jim Kelly
RB- Chuck Foreman
WR- Larry Brodsky
TE- My Homies Back at the Crib
OL- Mike Sullivan
DL- Ted Hendricks
LB- Rohan Marley.
DB- Ryan McNeil
S- Benny Blades
K- Danny Miller
P- Jeff Feagles


 
Last edited:
QB1: Kelly
RB1: McGahee
RB2: James
WR1: Irvin
WR2: A.Johnson
Slot: Moss
TE1: Winslow JR.
TE2: Shockey
OT: Mckinnie
Interior line: Otto

DL: Brown, Kennedy, Sapp, Maryland
LB:Lewis, Morgan, Armstead
S: Taylor, Reed/B.Blades
CB: Rolle, McNeil
 
HarryCarayisGoat said:
QB- Toretta
RB- McGahee
WR- Moss
TE- Winslow
OL- McKinnie
DL- Sapp
LB- Ray Lewis
DB- Rolle
S- Reed
K- Huerta
P- Bosher

Who ya got?
Click to expand...


Dude if your going by what they did at Miami and Miami alone you got 3 correct, **** arguably only 2. That is if you mean AT MIAMI.

QB - Vinnie
RB - OJ Anderson. Melvin Bratton/Edge are arguable.
Flanker - Playmaker
Split End - Reggie Wayne/Andre Johnson
Slot - Moss
FB - Highsmith. Nick Luchey (Williams) was **** nice but Zo' was it.
TE - Bubba. Just my opinion god we've been blessed since Alfredo Roberts.
OT - Searcy. Love Mt. Mc. But Searcy was the same AND a leader.
C - KC Jones
G - Bibla
DE - Stork
DT - Brown. No one at UM was better while at UM and god we've been more blessed here than TE, Vince, Sapp, Tez, Maryland...)
Mike - Ray
SAM - Darrin Smith
Will - Dan Morgan
Safety - Brian Blades
CB - Ryan McNeil
K - Boshman!
P - Feagles
 
Back
Top