They actually tout that committee, the ones who pick the four teams. Network analysts are allowed to visit briefly. They invariably report on how sophisticated it is, how impressive. Meanwhile, I'd like to bet the phrase "pass defense" doesn't show up all season in those meetings. Not once. Strength of schedule is an invention of idiots and applied by morons. It requires literally zero insight or ability. That's why it is a perfect vehicle for this young brainwashed generation. People who grew up in the horse racing generations experienced the dilemmas every day, the horse emerging from a Grade 1 race competing against horses who had raced in upper tier allowance races. Company kept or company vanquished is merely one criteria, and hardly the dominant one, as often as not. This young football generation doesn't look for hidden but devastating variables like pass defense because they have been taught that strength of schedule is all that really matters. So sad.
When you allow entry to a team that gives up 7.2 yards per pass attempt like Michigan State, you are asking for a result like this. As I posted last night on a Dolphins forum, it was like a mini bye for Alabama. I know I mentioned that 7.2 here several weeks ago. It made for an easy wager but otherwise it's a disgusting development for college football. That Ohio State/Michigan State outcome a month ago ruined the postseason, especially once the pathetic pass defense team drew Alabama for opponent. Michigan State 2015 plays well off the line of scrimmage to allow easy underneath completions, but they combine that with horrid deep coverage. Quite a menu. And this is with a very good front line. Imagine how inept that pass defense would be with a mediocre front wall. Scary.
Last season Florida State was allowing more than 7 yards per attempt. They were assassinated by Oregon. And the trend will continue as long as that committee is dense enough to look away. Anyone who votes for a terrible pass defense team as member of the final four should be charged with multiple felonies. Once again the national champ will be among the best in pass defense. Clemson and Alabama each allow less than 6 yards per attempt.
Oklahoma did also. I didn't bet that game but I rooted for Clemson, not only to support the ACC but mostly to deny the Big 12. That conference is such a shell game it doesn't deserve any praise or a spot in the final four, let alone the final two. The Sooners made a dramatic rise in pass defense and overall defense this year, which was plenty in a conference that otherwise doesn't pretend to play defense at all but they were worn down and exposed today. I had my doubts about Oklahoma given the degree that Tennessee toyed with them for three quarters. That margin should have been far beyond 17-0 before the Vols initiated the choke.
I'm sure lots of Canes fans rooted for Michigan State in that game at Columbus, still fretting our Fiesta Bowl outcome. Meanwhile, this Saban era has every potential to dwarf anything the Canes accomplished in the '80s and beyond. This can be 4 titles in 7 years. He hasn't lost in the final game, like Miami so often. There are no tendencies to not score many points in bowl games, like the Canes beginning in 1985. In short, that's why I root against Alabama every year. This is another season in which they are going to be excused a home defeat en route to the title game. The Canes never benefited from that but for Alabama and particularly under Saban it has become one of the great traditions in college football, right up there with Traveler at the Coliseum. As I posted at the time, that Mississippi victory was a monumental fluke, accomplished via weird deflections and turnovers and unlikely big plays that succeeded by an eyelash. If you lined up those teams the very next day I would have been confident in Alabama by double digits.
I'll root for Clemson. They have enough permutations to give the Tide some trouble. But Alabama very seldom loses when its defense is of this caliber. The key numbers all year have been dramatically improved from the subpar units of 2013 and 2014. I suspect we'll see a considerably more Derrick Henry game plan this time, running smack at Clemson to break their will and assert the physical pecking order.
This matchup is the opposite of SEC vs. ACC title game two seasons ago, when the ACC team owned the superior defense.