Search results

I already spent part of my life workin for the man, but if @DMoney wants to bring me on as the resident criminal law expert im all ears.

Yes, the memo would document the reasons for declining the charges. As I explained earlier In the the thread it's likely that the victim told the state shes not willing to cooperate and signed a waiver of prosecution. State can't prove it without her or an independent witness. Could it be...

Sure, although I could submit a public records request to the Miami sao for the no action memo but I'd rather not 😂

I explained why thats not necessarily the case on page 12 or 13 I believe. It could be the case but more likely than not its something else.

Again for the millionth time, he wasnt found "not guilty" the state declined to file charges. That is not the same as being found not guilty by a jury.

That's a broad generalization that is extremely inaccurate. But now you've certainly peaked my interest as to what qualifies you to render such an opinion. Again I've been practicing criminal law in the state for over a decade, 5 as a prosecutor and 6 as a defense attorney. Are there some legal...

That's not necessarily true, see explanation above. Although some SAOs may pick up the case, they cant prove it without a witness, a video or other independent injury. Broward might still file it with the injuries but as soon as i set that case for trial and the victim doesn't show the case gets...

Evidence of injuries doesn't always mean a successful prosecution, the usual explanation is that the victim became uncooperative and tells the state they dont want to go forward or they recant the story. If the victim refuses to testify or recants the only way the state can prove the case is...

It's brutal, every other jurisdiction i can pull everything online, even in the small Podunk counties in the state let you do it, but not miami.

your analysis is also incorrect because the state has filed a no action and the case is now officially closed. You can see my explanation a few posts up

To clarify since a lot of you are confused, here is what happened Tae wasn't found "Not guilty" The Miami dade SAO filed what's called a "No Action". When a case is no actioned it means miami is declining to file charges against the defendant. It can happen for many reasons. In Domestic...

There wasn't a trial. Miami declined to file charges against him.

He cant because there is no link. Miami doesnt make these documents available for online viewing. Also he wasn't found "Not guilty" The Miami dade SAO filed what's called a "No Action". When a case is no actioned it means miami is declining to file charges against the defendant. It can happen...

Miami doesn't post it online, you have to email and request it. Miami Dade is one of the few clerk of courts in the state that doesn't have online viewing for the majority of documents. As a criminal defense practitioner its extremely aggravating.