It's tough. I'd give them the edge based off 3-1, but we're their only upper tier series win and we were better in conference. The 3-1 is unfortunate for us but it was 4 home games for them.
Yes he was clearly tagged and Gil did nothing to drag the runner off the base. The runner grabbed Gil's wrist and his momentum carried him off. Being irrationally angry at other factors doesn't change the reality of the situation.