I could see Waters shirting this year. Scott, Dorsett, Hurns, Malcom Lewis, Lockhart, Crawford, Thompkins will all be our 'active' WRs this season IMO. I could see Waters getting that redshirt this season.
Herb is definitely an athlete playing football right now. He has a nice skillset just needs some fine tuning. It didn't look like he was running that fast but he was eating up some angles there.
Cunningham was abusing them boys. What kind of competition is he playing against?