Search results

  1. Cookie917

    Goat

    Who is the best QB to ever play then? I guess our definitions of "luck" differ, luck to me is the helmet catch, or the edleman bobbling catch that bounced off a guys leg in Atlanta, those were just lucky, a guy lining up offsides then having to ask his coach "was i?" after the play is not...
  2. Cookie917

    Goat

    I agree some of the superbowls he won because of good to great defenses and scheme where he did not need to be all world but.... XXXVIII: Patriots 32, Panthers 29 • Brady went 32–for–48 with 354 yards, three touchdowns and one interception XLIX: Patriots 28, Seahawks 24 Brady went...
  3. Cookie917

    Goat

    I never said that you said he wasn't great, I said your statement of "its not close" was over the top. Just like now you are digging yourself a deeper hole.... lets see: (McVay said he was outcoached) what do you expect McVay to say? blame his players? his scheme? no you give credit to a HC...
  4. Cookie917

    Goat

    I give it to you that you are smart in arguing a position you can't lose lol of course you can poke holes in a resume, and have the same argument of if "Named QB" was on the Jags or Raiders, they wouldn't have had the same success but you also hedge in saying there is no GOAT at QB so you could...
  5. Cookie917

    Goat

    IDK a couple of your statements seem over the top and take away from what I think is an otherwise valid argument.... Calling the Rams offense incompetent for that game is fine, but prior to that game Mcvay was the wizz-kid, offensive mastermind and the rams that averaged the second most points...
Back
Top