Shannon Dawson is out-coaching people right now. The red zone is the one place where you can see exactly who’s missing.
David Lake of 247Sports went through the film and the numbers on how our offense changed after Malachi Toney went down: how defenses are playing us, who’s stepping up, and our pass protection. Here’s the conversation.
Q: You dove into the offense too, which is a more encouraging story. What’s changed since Malachi went down?
David Lake: This is all in the margins. Miami isn’t making drastic changes. But the first thing you notice is how defenses are approaching Miami. Over the first eight games, Miami’s most common look was cover 3, at 32% of snaps. In the last two games, against Notre Dame and Duke, it’s been cover 1 on 58% of snaps.
Man-free loads the box. It says: if you want to run into a heavy box, go ahead, and we think our corners can cover your receivers.
Why don’t teams do it when Malachi plays? Because he destroys man coverage. On the season he’s averaging 20.8 yards per catch against cover 1, with 353 yards and three touchdowns. Stanford played a lot of cover 1 in the opener, and 165 of his yards and two of his touchdowns that day came against it.
Q: So the receivers have to answer that. What has Dawson done with the personnel he has?
David Lake: I think he’s done a really good job. I’m not throwing shade, but Miami doesn’t have receivers right now who just beat you deep, with raw speed or by winning jump balls. They have guys who win one-on-one in the quick game, like Cooper Barkate on slants, crossers and screens.
They have really good blocking receivers for the screen game. They have really good running backs, and we’re seeing more two-back formations. Dawson is asking his players to do what they can do, not telling Daylyn Upshaw to go be Malachi because he’s the new slot guy. The depth of target is shorter.
The one thing worth monitoring is the red zone. Before he got hurt, Miami scored a touchdown on 81% of red zone trips. In two games since, it’s dropped to 55%. Small sample, but it makes sense.
He’s a cheat code. Call a slant and he wins it. Call a fade and a 5-foot-9 receiver wins it. And he draws so much attention that it’s easier to run it in, too. I’m not a big play-call critic, but in the red zone I think we’ve seen Dawson reach a little on quarterback runs, and I think that’s a result of not having Malachi.
Q: Let’s talk about the two-back sets, because Dawson alluded to it too.
David Lake: You want your coach to get the best players on the field together. And these aren’t usually flashy plays. Sometimes they’re explosive, but mostly they’re success-rate plays that keep you ahead of the chains. When I rewatch them, Dawson is in his bag. Play-action, then he spits it out to a back in the flat instead of handing it off.
There was a back-to-back sequence against Duke I loved. Girard Pringle Jr. motions out to the flat, they hit him, and he gets about ten yards. The very next play, from the left hash, Pringle motions out to the right side. Duke gets sucked into that action, Barkate runs a tunnel screen the other way, and he turns it up for a nice gain. Dawson is toying with people with those designs.
Q: We’ve also seen Lofton everywhere: tight end in two-back sets, fullback in an old-school I-formation for the touchdown against FSU, split backs. What intrigues me is short yardage. Put Fletcher at fullback, Mallory at tailback, and keep Lofton at tight end.
David Lake: The versatility is exciting, and I want to see it with Malachi when he’s back at 100%. Two-back sets were 7.4% of snaps with him, which is still probably top 40 nationally. Without him it’s about 15%, more like top 15 or top 20. They’re going to it more, and it’s the right call. And it was great to see Jordan Lyle come online in this game, too.
Q: You also verified something everybody watching has seen: Darian Mensah is buying more time.
David Lake: Without Malachi, Barkate stepped up and the backs stepped up, and Mensah has to step up too.
With Malachi he’s the point guard getting the ball out, and that’s good. Without him, there are times he has to create. His average depth of target is down, but his average time to throw is up. The offensive line isn’t holding up great against pressure these last two weeks, but his pressure-to-sack rate is going down, especially when he holds the ball longer than two and a half seconds. He has that sixth sense. I don’t have a great explanation other than that he’s feeling it, not sitting in the pocket looking for Malachi.
There was a play I loved late in the fourth quarter against Duke, with Miami up one score. Third-and-7, pressure coming, Mensah does his spin out of the pocket, rolls, and finds Barkate right at the sticks for a contested catch and a first down. He won’t have to do that every time. But when your line isn’t consistent, you have to come up big in some spots, and he’s doing it.
Q: Here’s one for you. Going off TeamRankings, FBS games only: 3.6% of Mensah’s dropbacks end in sacks, 20th in the nation. In 2024, with Cam Ward behind that great line of Jalen Rivers, Anez Cooper, Francis Mauigoa and Markel Bell, it was 4.4%, 31st. Mensah is meaningfully better.
David Lake: His average time to throw that year was 2.9 seconds, and some games were over three. Against Florida, Iowa State and Cal he was in that range. Anything close to three is a long time. Subtract the screens and the numbers probably move a bit, but it fits.
They need to turn the offensive line around over these next two games, specifically pass protection. The numbers are getting close to 2022 territory, and that line was horrific.
David Lake: Miami is allowing pressure on 29.1% of dropbacks right now. In 2022 it was 31.6%, 62nd in the country. Run blocking isn’t comparable, to be clear. But pass protection has to start trending the right way quickly.
Every chart from this conversation is in the full video on the CanesInsight YouTube channel. Subscribe so you catch David’s numbers every week.
David Lake of 247Sports went through the film and the numbers on how our offense changed after Malachi Toney went down: how defenses are playing us, who’s stepping up, and our pass protection. Here’s the conversation.
Q: You dove into the offense too, which is a more encouraging story. What’s changed since Malachi went down?
David Lake: This is all in the margins. Miami isn’t making drastic changes. But the first thing you notice is how defenses are approaching Miami. Over the first eight games, Miami’s most common look was cover 3, at 32% of snaps. In the last two games, against Notre Dame and Duke, it’s been cover 1 on 58% of snaps.
Man-free loads the box. It says: if you want to run into a heavy box, go ahead, and we think our corners can cover your receivers.
Why don’t teams do it when Malachi plays? Because he destroys man coverage. On the season he’s averaging 20.8 yards per catch against cover 1, with 353 yards and three touchdowns. Stanford played a lot of cover 1 in the opener, and 165 of his yards and two of his touchdowns that day came against it.
Q: So the receivers have to answer that. What has Dawson done with the personnel he has?
David Lake: I think he’s done a really good job. I’m not throwing shade, but Miami doesn’t have receivers right now who just beat you deep, with raw speed or by winning jump balls. They have guys who win one-on-one in the quick game, like Cooper Barkate on slants, crossers and screens.
They have really good blocking receivers for the screen game. They have really good running backs, and we’re seeing more two-back formations. Dawson is asking his players to do what they can do, not telling Daylyn Upshaw to go be Malachi because he’s the new slot guy. The depth of target is shorter.
The one thing worth monitoring is the red zone. Before he got hurt, Miami scored a touchdown on 81% of red zone trips. In two games since, it’s dropped to 55%. Small sample, but it makes sense.
He’s a cheat code. Call a slant and he wins it. Call a fade and a 5-foot-9 receiver wins it. And he draws so much attention that it’s easier to run it in, too. I’m not a big play-call critic, but in the red zone I think we’ve seen Dawson reach a little on quarterback runs, and I think that’s a result of not having Malachi.
Q: Let’s talk about the two-back sets, because Dawson alluded to it too.
David Lake: You want your coach to get the best players on the field together. And these aren’t usually flashy plays. Sometimes they’re explosive, but mostly they’re success-rate plays that keep you ahead of the chains. When I rewatch them, Dawson is in his bag. Play-action, then he spits it out to a back in the flat instead of handing it off.
There was a back-to-back sequence against Duke I loved. Girard Pringle Jr. motions out to the flat, they hit him, and he gets about ten yards. The very next play, from the left hash, Pringle motions out to the right side. Duke gets sucked into that action, Barkate runs a tunnel screen the other way, and he turns it up for a nice gain. Dawson is toying with people with those designs.
Q: We’ve also seen Lofton everywhere: tight end in two-back sets, fullback in an old-school I-formation for the touchdown against FSU, split backs. What intrigues me is short yardage. Put Fletcher at fullback, Mallory at tailback, and keep Lofton at tight end.
David Lake: The versatility is exciting, and I want to see it with Malachi when he’s back at 100%. Two-back sets were 7.4% of snaps with him, which is still probably top 40 nationally. Without him it’s about 15%, more like top 15 or top 20. They’re going to it more, and it’s the right call. And it was great to see Jordan Lyle come online in this game, too.
Q: You also verified something everybody watching has seen: Darian Mensah is buying more time.
David Lake: Without Malachi, Barkate stepped up and the backs stepped up, and Mensah has to step up too.
With Malachi he’s the point guard getting the ball out, and that’s good. Without him, there are times he has to create. His average depth of target is down, but his average time to throw is up. The offensive line isn’t holding up great against pressure these last two weeks, but his pressure-to-sack rate is going down, especially when he holds the ball longer than two and a half seconds. He has that sixth sense. I don’t have a great explanation other than that he’s feeling it, not sitting in the pocket looking for Malachi.
There was a play I loved late in the fourth quarter against Duke, with Miami up one score. Third-and-7, pressure coming, Mensah does his spin out of the pocket, rolls, and finds Barkate right at the sticks for a contested catch and a first down. He won’t have to do that every time. But when your line isn’t consistent, you have to come up big in some spots, and he’s doing it.
Q: Here’s one for you. Going off TeamRankings, FBS games only: 3.6% of Mensah’s dropbacks end in sacks, 20th in the nation. In 2024, with Cam Ward behind that great line of Jalen Rivers, Anez Cooper, Francis Mauigoa and Markel Bell, it was 4.4%, 31st. Mensah is meaningfully better.
David Lake: His average time to throw that year was 2.9 seconds, and some games were over three. Against Florida, Iowa State and Cal he was in that range. Anything close to three is a long time. Subtract the screens and the numbers probably move a bit, but it fits.
They need to turn the offensive line around over these next two games, specifically pass protection. The numbers are getting close to 2022 territory, and that line was horrific.
David Lake: Miami is allowing pressure on 29.1% of dropbacks right now. In 2022 it was 31.6%, 62nd in the country. Run blocking isn’t comparable, to be clear. But pass protection has to start trending the right way quickly.
Every chart from this conversation is in the full video on the CanesInsight YouTube channel. Subscribe so you catch David’s numbers every week.