How the SEC's NIL contract just helped Miami

CanesInSight Articles
5 min read
The SEC just handed us a recruiting pitch, and it didn't cost us a dime.

The conference has a new standard NIL contract, and the agents hate it.

One of them, talking to 247Sports, said that if he were the Big Ten, Texas Tech or Miami, he'd be thrilled and telling the SEC to roll it out. Another agency was blunter about the template: "we can't sign."

When the people who represent most of the top recruits and portal players in the country say that, schools outside the SEC should be paying attention.

Here's how we got here. The power conferences wanted Congress to bail them out with the Protect College Sports Act. Miami opposed it because the expansion language would have limited our ability to leave. The bill stalled. In court, the NCAA gets beaten like a drum pretty much every time. So the conferences are trying self-governance: get every school to agree on one contract, enforce it, and make the players be the ones to sue. The Big Ten did it first. The SEC's version is worse.

The word unconscionable is being thrown around, so let's break it down. That's a contract so one-sided that nobody in good conscience would sign it, and a court shouldn't enforce it.

Start with the gag order. Once you sign, you can't talk to other schools. Neither can your agent. Talk to one without notifying your own school and it's a material breach. That isn't how the business works right now. Agents who represent dozens of players routinely send schools portal lists of guys who are thinking about leaving, so programs can plan rosters and line up money. Under the SEC form, that's off the table. You're in the dark until you actually enter the portal.

And the school might not have to let you do that. The form says a school doesn't have to enter your name if you're under contract. Miami fans know this one as the Xavier Lucas situation. Lucas wanted out of Wisconsin, and Wisconsin said he was under contract and they didn't have to put his name in. He left anyway. There's a lawsuit, but they couldn't stop him, because refusing to enter a player who asks to go in is against NCAA bylaws.

The SEC is trying to waive that right by contract. You can waive some rights by contract, but courts are going to ask whether the NCAA ever meant for portal entry to be waivable. Everything the courts have done lately has pushed toward more player movement, not less.

Then there's the buyout. Liquidated damages are set at 50% of what's left on the deal. Take a quarterback out of high school on a three-year deal paying $2 million, then $4 million, then $4 million. He wants out after year one. He owes half of the remaining $8 million, which is $4 million.

He made $2 million and owes $4 million just to leave.

The signing bonus isn't really yours either. Under the SEC form, the school can claw it back if you leave early for the portal or the draft. That's going to be a shock to an 18-year-old who thinks the money is in his pocket.

It keeps going. Section 3.3 lets a school reduce or withhold payments, on written notice, for rules violations or for conduct that materially diminishes NIL or institutional brand value. The SEC says athletes get ten days to fix it, but the language doesn't spell out what conduct counts.

One example is excessive unexcused class or tutor absences, with no number attached. Another is injuries from "dangerous activities." Darren Heitner, the South Florida agent we've had on the show, flagged an optional addendum that lets a school adjust pay downward if an administrator decides, in his sole judgment, that the athlete shows a "general lack of enthusiasm." What does that mean?

There's also an insurance clause. If a player buys his own disability coverage and collects on it after an injury, that money counts against his NIL payments. The school effectively becomes the beneficiary of a policy the player paid for. That's bizarre.

And if a player and school both want to change any of this? They can't do it on their own. Any deviation from the form needs league approval, which can take weeks.

People will say that's how pro contracts work. It isn't. NFL, NBA and MLB contracts are strict, sure. But those rules were collectively bargained with a players' union. There's no union here.

This is the strictness of the pros without the bargaining and without the balance of power. One side wrote it and is shoving it down the players' throats.

Ahmmon Richards put it simply on our show: "There is no way any player with two brain cells signs to an SEC team with that language."

His point was about the guy in the middle. The five-star headed for the first round won't feel it. The four-star or three-star who gets over-recruited will. He compared it to the days before the portal, when leaving meant junior college or sitting out a year. Same idea, new paperwork. Make leaving hurt so much you don't try.

According to 247Sports, notable contract extensions are on pause, multiple major agencies have concerns, and front office people inside the SEC are worried these terms push recruits toward friendlier places.

Every SEC school just made its offer worse on paper. We didn't. That's a pitch this staff gets to make in every living room and every portal conversation this winter.

We broke down every clause with slides in the full video on our YouTube channel, so go watch it there.

 

Comments (0)

Back
Top