How about Michigan? Or Muschamp? He actually LOST to the awful Golden with an equally or more talented team!
Butch Jones, hands down. Very few programs have the tradition, money, support, academic standards, brand, campus and intangibles to be a winner. Couple that with circumstance(sec east in a down year) and he's just as bad as Alfred. He'll forever be known as the guy who failed at Tennessee, same as Golden.