Taylor or Reed

[CoCaneHead]

Yeah I would go with Ed reed but it's not fair cause Sean passed away so young... But Ed reed is arguebally the best safety ever..

 

[crossover22[]_[]]

Athletically its taylor all day but to build a defense around its got to be reed. He can direct a defense and makes plays on the ball.

They are two of the best to ever play at miami

 

[Ethnicsands]

Taylor, IMO, he's the most physically gifted player ever to play period.

fify

+1

I've never seen a better athlete on the football field.

Obviously you have to project a bit given ST didn't get to hit his prime, but ST was the most dominant DB I've ever seen in college, and as D$ mentioned, he had made two pro bowls by 25 -- reed showed up in the league at 24.

People underestimate Taylor's instincts, ball skills and football smarts because his athletic ability was so obvious. I've never seen a better S. Again, if you are going to judge ST against the veteran Reed, it's a pointless conversation. But IMO ST was on track to eclipse Reed. And I love reed.

Like swagger said, sick that we had them so close together.