As for Randy Philips, correct me if I'm wrong, but I seem to recall that he's made a good effort to make up for his past sins. He's tried to repair his relationship with the school and overall just tried to make up for the fact that he snitched. If he did that and went to great lengths to do that, I can be cool with it, but yeah, his sins are tough to overlook.
Not like Aldarius, whose eligibility was roasted when he refused to snitch on the school.