I rewatched the game - just our offensive plays. My main reason was to figure out wtf is going on with Stacey Coley, but here's my comments overall.
James Coley:
The Good - I thought it was a really well called game. He involved the TE and Duke in the passing game. He used the middle of the field. The plays made sense for the down/distance/situation. No random "what were you thinking???" calls. He didn't shackle Kayaa, and didn't ask him to do too much either.
The Bad - Substitution patterns (I get into that below). Too many bubble screens (8 total). The "BS" worked a little better when Walford was split out wide, but most of the time it's Dorsett or Berrios trying to be lead blockers (unsuccessfully). The 2 minute offense...I'm not sure we have one. We got the ball down 17 with 4 minutes left and all 3 timeouts. Highly unlikely we come back, but you at least try, right? We never hurried and still looked to the sidelines for plays. At least run the 2 minute drill so Kayaa gets experience with it. I have a feeling if we had the ball down 5 with 2 minutes left, our offense would've looked like a circus.
Offensive Line
Played pretty well. Gregory is a beast so you can't hold him down the whole game, but Kayaa had time to throw. There were holes in the running game, more so in the 1st half than 2nd, but I never thought the OL got manhandled.
Kaaya
The Good - He could end up being special. I've heard the "We have our QB!" line before - Wright (FSU 05), Harris (FSU 09), Morris (He's gonna be a 1st round pick!) - but I believe this one. He's gaining confidence. He already has the things that you can't teach (size) or are hardest to teach (accuracy, poise, reading defenses, making progressions), and will continue to get better. He was on the money almost all night and the two picks - I thought Walford could've fought harder, and the 4th & 4 was just a tough situation/bad read.
The Bad - He doesn't have the strength to throw a good deep ball yet IMO. We went long twice - 1 was a duck (Dorsett blew right past the CB), and the other a jump ball (Dorsett made a great play - but jump balls aren't really any of our WR's strength). I know he hit Dorsett twice against Ak St. & FAMU, but one was late and hung up there for too long. Throws over 20 yards down field, lack accuracy and zip at this point IMO. I saw some small mistakes still - backfoot throws, not throwing the ball away, not watching the play clock - but experience and physical maturity will solve those things.
Wide Receivers
Stacey Coley - He lined up for 4 Offensive plays. Just 4. 3 bubble screens thrown to him, and another bubble screen where he was a decoy. The shoulder was still bothering him after the first one he caught. He was on the field for a 2 plays in our last drive, but so was Yearby for the first time all game, so I chalk that up Coley's wtf 2 minute drill.
So for the stupid "Coley hasn't done anything" and "Coley has regressed" comments that will pop up this week, here's a couple things - 1) He's been hurt the last 2 games 2) He got the ball 3 out of the 4 times he was on the field and 5 of our first 10 passes at Louisville were intended for Coley (we know we need to get him the ball). He's still our 2nd best playmaker behind Duke, so I expect Coley to blow up as soon as he's healthy again.
2 WR Sets - This was almost exclusively Dorsett and Berrios. Dorsett and Lewis was the only other combo.
3 WR Sets - This was always Dorsett/Berrios/Lewis (Walford was split wide too pretty often)
4 WR sets - Waters was mostly the 4th WR, but he only got in when we used 4 WR's. Coley was the only other WR used.
This is just weird to me. Berrios almost never left the field and was the first option probably more than any other WR. My assumption is that Kaaya is most comfortable with Berrios, who I like, but don't think should be getting THAT much playing time at this point. Seems hard to believe he's already jumped ahead of Lewis and Waters. Walford was probably split wide as a WR more than Waters saw the field. It worked, but I think Herb needs to see the field more, and we should switch up the WR combos. All played a really good game (outside of the Berrios drop).
Running Backs
Duke is Duke - our best player/weapon/leader by far, and he's fighting hard as **** out there. I still think the extra weight has taken away some speed & agility. Not saying he's slow, he's still fast as ****, just not AS fast or AS quick. But I understand he needs the weight....because Coley is going to run his *** into the ground again. If Duke is going to get 25-30 touches a game, Coley HAS GOT to start mixing in other RB's earlier and more often. It'll keep Duke fresh for the 4th quarter of games, and help him stay healthy for the full season. Duke is not a 230 lb. workhorse. Which leads me to...
Gus/Yearby/Gray - I don't care who you prefer, but 1 of them has to start getting more carries. In the 1st half of our 4 games, Gus has 2 carries and Yearby has 1 (don't get me started on Ron Regula). That just can't happen. Duke can't only come out when he's physically exhausted (which he is on a lot of plays where he's still in). It's going to get him hurt again if we never rotate in another RB.
James Coley:
The Good - I thought it was a really well called game. He involved the TE and Duke in the passing game. He used the middle of the field. The plays made sense for the down/distance/situation. No random "what were you thinking???" calls. He didn't shackle Kayaa, and didn't ask him to do too much either.
The Bad - Substitution patterns (I get into that below). Too many bubble screens (8 total). The "BS" worked a little better when Walford was split out wide, but most of the time it's Dorsett or Berrios trying to be lead blockers (unsuccessfully). The 2 minute offense...I'm not sure we have one. We got the ball down 17 with 4 minutes left and all 3 timeouts. Highly unlikely we come back, but you at least try, right? We never hurried and still looked to the sidelines for plays. At least run the 2 minute drill so Kayaa gets experience with it. I have a feeling if we had the ball down 5 with 2 minutes left, our offense would've looked like a circus.
Offensive Line
Played pretty well. Gregory is a beast so you can't hold him down the whole game, but Kayaa had time to throw. There were holes in the running game, more so in the 1st half than 2nd, but I never thought the OL got manhandled.
Kaaya
The Good - He could end up being special. I've heard the "We have our QB!" line before - Wright (FSU 05), Harris (FSU 09), Morris (He's gonna be a 1st round pick!) - but I believe this one. He's gaining confidence. He already has the things that you can't teach (size) or are hardest to teach (accuracy, poise, reading defenses, making progressions), and will continue to get better. He was on the money almost all night and the two picks - I thought Walford could've fought harder, and the 4th & 4 was just a tough situation/bad read.
The Bad - He doesn't have the strength to throw a good deep ball yet IMO. We went long twice - 1 was a duck (Dorsett blew right past the CB), and the other a jump ball (Dorsett made a great play - but jump balls aren't really any of our WR's strength). I know he hit Dorsett twice against Ak St. & FAMU, but one was late and hung up there for too long. Throws over 20 yards down field, lack accuracy and zip at this point IMO. I saw some small mistakes still - backfoot throws, not throwing the ball away, not watching the play clock - but experience and physical maturity will solve those things.
Wide Receivers
Stacey Coley - He lined up for 4 Offensive plays. Just 4. 3 bubble screens thrown to him, and another bubble screen where he was a decoy. The shoulder was still bothering him after the first one he caught. He was on the field for a 2 plays in our last drive, but so was Yearby for the first time all game, so I chalk that up Coley's wtf 2 minute drill.
So for the stupid "Coley hasn't done anything" and "Coley has regressed" comments that will pop up this week, here's a couple things - 1) He's been hurt the last 2 games 2) He got the ball 3 out of the 4 times he was on the field and 5 of our first 10 passes at Louisville were intended for Coley (we know we need to get him the ball). He's still our 2nd best playmaker behind Duke, so I expect Coley to blow up as soon as he's healthy again.
2 WR Sets - This was almost exclusively Dorsett and Berrios. Dorsett and Lewis was the only other combo.
3 WR Sets - This was always Dorsett/Berrios/Lewis (Walford was split wide too pretty often)
4 WR sets - Waters was mostly the 4th WR, but he only got in when we used 4 WR's. Coley was the only other WR used.
This is just weird to me. Berrios almost never left the field and was the first option probably more than any other WR. My assumption is that Kaaya is most comfortable with Berrios, who I like, but don't think should be getting THAT much playing time at this point. Seems hard to believe he's already jumped ahead of Lewis and Waters. Walford was probably split wide as a WR more than Waters saw the field. It worked, but I think Herb needs to see the field more, and we should switch up the WR combos. All played a really good game (outside of the Berrios drop).
Running Backs
Duke is Duke - our best player/weapon/leader by far, and he's fighting hard as **** out there. I still think the extra weight has taken away some speed & agility. Not saying he's slow, he's still fast as ****, just not AS fast or AS quick. But I understand he needs the weight....because Coley is going to run his *** into the ground again. If Duke is going to get 25-30 touches a game, Coley HAS GOT to start mixing in other RB's earlier and more often. It'll keep Duke fresh for the 4th quarter of games, and help him stay healthy for the full season. Duke is not a 230 lb. workhorse. Which leads me to...
Gus/Yearby/Gray - I don't care who you prefer, but 1 of them has to start getting more carries. In the 1st half of our 4 games, Gus has 2 carries and Yearby has 1 (don't get me started on Ron Regula). That just can't happen. Duke can't only come out when he's physically exhausted (which he is on a lot of plays where he's still in). It's going to get him hurt again if we never rotate in another RB.
Last edited:
