My top 10 (Miami) players for the '25 regular season...

k9cane

Senior
Joined
Nov 20, 2011
Messages
9,836
So the #Canes regular season is over, they went 10-2 and earned a playoff bid. They play Texas A@M in Kyle Field next weekend. Here's one fans view of the top 10 players, not really just about stats but general impact and consistently good play throughout the year. I don't use PFF numbers or any analytics, again, just my overall view of all 12 games that I watched (and I literally saw every play of every game)

Again, I'm no expert, but just a guy who tunes into the games and formulates some opinions. Like pound-for-pound lists in boxing, this isn't to be taken all too seriously. Just a fun list to highlight those who have stood out for Miami in '25.

1- Malachi Toney: What else can be said? This true freshman is the most unique offensive weapon in UM history. We've seen triple-threats (receiving, running and kick/punt returns) at Miami, guys like Santana, Kevin Williams and Travis Benjamin, but Toney, is the rare quadruple-threat (his passing skills are QB-like). Should be in the Heisman discussion coming into next season. Toney just put up the greatest true freshman season in Miami history.

2- Ruben Bain : stats don't tell the whole story (4.5 sacks), Bain is a guy that elevates those around him as offenses game plan for him upfront. Biggest compliment I can pay him as that he could have played on any of the title winning teams in Miami's past.

3- Akheem Mesidor- If Bain is Crockett, then 'Mes' is 'Tubbs' and they formed the modern day 'Miami Vice'. These two might be the best overall Miami bookends edging out Kenard Lang/Kenny Holmes ,Jerome McDougle/Andrew Williams and Rusty Meaderis/Kevin Patrick and Darren Krein

4- Francis Mauignoa- since day one as a true freshman has held down the right tackle spot at a high level. He and Bain will leave Miami as first round draft choices.

5- Jakobe Thomas -- a physical enforcer who also showed he can play in space(led the team with 4 INT's). He and Z. Poyser upgraded Miami's safety play by leaps and bounds this season.

6- Keionte Scott- before his injury, 'Agent O' was in the contention for the Thorpe Award. His return would be huge in the playoffs

7- Carson Beck-- had some mid-season yips, but overall had a strong season, completing nearly 75-percent of his passes. Eventually developed strong chemistry (despite missing spring ball) with a relatively inexperienced set of receivers. Ultimately, his legacy will be in how far he can lead this team in the playoffs

8- Damari Brown - rarely did you hear his name called this season at corner. He is one of the reasons why this was the most improved aspect of the team. Really bounced back after an injury plagued '24 campaign

9- Ahmad Moten - made the leap late in the year from a reliable rotational piece to a guy who began to really become a standout inside the trenches. He is the very epitome of the 'player development' that Mario Cristobal speaks off.

10- Mark Fletcher/Girard Pringle -- Alright, Im hedging here a bit, but while it's easy to highlight the spark that Pringle gave the running game late in the season, it was Fletcher who was the steady reliable inside runner that this offense needs. He averaged just a shade under five yards a carry and had 10 touchdowns. As for Pringle, well, the offense just looked different (and more explosive) as he became a bigger part of the offense...

Honorable mention: Keelan Marion, Carter Davis, Markel Bell, Zechariah Poyser, CJ Daniels
 
Advertisement
Great list- good write up.

My M. Toney addition: I’d maybe offer that Toney has some Roscoe Parrish in him as much or more than some of those dudes. (Wasn’t Roscoe also a HS QB and also did some throws off of some of his sets while he was here?)
 
Good list Steve. I might sneak one guy into the list up from honorable mention. I was really nervous about the kicking game when we lost borregales. But man Carter Davis has been almost as good. 14-16 he’s hit long field goals he hit one late vs nd to win. and he’s been even better on kickoffs. Was expecting the kicking game to fall off some.
 
Can't argue with any of that.
IMO we will live and die with Beck now. If he stays hot, we can go far, if he has a clunker we won't.
Not earth-shattering, I know, but...
I forget where I read it, but someone estimated that he finally caught up on his missed reps around the SMU game and has gone 11-1 td/int since.
 
Good list Steve. I might sneak one guy into the list up from honorable mention. I was really nervous about the kicking game when we lost borregales. But man Carter Davis has been almost as good. 14-16 he’s hit long field goals he hit one late vs nd to win. and he’s been even better on kickoffs. Was expecting the kicking game to fall off some.
The Notre dame kick was huge. No gimme.
 
Good list Steve. I might sneak one guy into the list up from honorable mention. I was really nervous about the kicking game when we lost borregales. But man Carter Davis has been almost as good. 14-16 he’s hit long field goals he hit one late vs nd to win. and he’s been even better on kickoffs. Was expecting the kicking game to fall off some.

He's been clutch this season, absolutely. But there was a lot of quality guys I just couldn't put him in front of. Which speaks to the quality of this squad
 
Hands up I thought Brown was a JAG going into this year and would get buried on the depth chart.
 
Advertisement
CJ Daniels has come up clutch every time he has been needed. Top 10 for sure.

We wouldn’t be in the playoffs without his circus catches vs ND, and to a lesser extent Pitt.

Edit: and FSU, and USF, and UF… he was EVERYWHERE!
 
Last edited:
So the #Canes regular season is over, they went 10-2 and earned a playoff bid. They play Texas A@M in Kyle Field next weekend. Here's one fans view of the top 10 players, not really just about stats but general impact and consistently good play throughout the year. I don't use PFF numbers or any analytics, again, just my overall view of all 12 games that I watched (and I literally saw every play of every game)

Again, I'm no expert, but just a guy who tunes into the games and formulates some opinions. Like pound-for-pound lists in boxing, this isn't to be taken all too seriously. Just a fun list to highlight those who have stood out for Miami in '25.

1- Malachi Toney: What else can be said? This true freshman is the most unique offensive weapon in UM history. We've seen triple-threats (receiving, running and kick/punt returns) at Miami, guys like Santana, Kevin Williams and Travis Benjamin, but Toney, is the rare quadruple-threat (his passing skills are QB-like). Should be in the Heisman discussion coming into next season. Toney just put up the greatest true freshman season in Miami history.

2- Ruben Bain : stats don't tell the whole story (4.5 sacks), Bain is a guy that elevates those around him as offenses game plan for him upfront. Biggest compliment I can pay him as that he could have played on any of the title winning teams in Miami's past.

3- Akheem Mesidor- If Bain is Crockett, then 'Mes' is 'Tubbs' and they formed the modern day 'Miami Vice'. These two might be the best overall Miami bookends edging out Kenard Lang/Kenny Holmes ,Jerome McDougle/Andrew Williams and Rusty Meaderis/Kevin Patrick and Darren Krein

4- Francis Mauignoa- since day one as a true freshman has held down the right tackle spot at a high level. He and Bain will leave Miami as first round draft choices.

5- Jakobe Thomas -- a physical enforcer who also showed he can play in space(led the team with 4 INT's). He and Z. Poyser upgraded Miami's safety play by leaps and bounds this season.

6- Keionte Scott- before his injury, 'Agent O' was in the contention for the Thorpe Award. His return would be huge in the playoffs

7- Carson Beck-- had some mid-season yips, but overall had a strong season, completing nearly 75-percent of his passes. Eventually developed strong chemistry (despite missing spring ball) with a relatively inexperienced set of receivers. Ultimately, his legacy will be in how far he can lead this team in the playoffs

8- Damari Brown - rarely did you hear his name called this season at corner. He is one of the reasons why this was the most improved aspect of the team. Really bounced back after an injury plagued '24 campaign

9- Ahmad Moten - made the leap late in the year from a reliable rotational piece to a guy who began to really become a standout inside the trenches. He is the very epitome of the 'player development' that Mario Cristobal speaks off.

10- Mark Fletcher/Girard Pringle -- Alright, Im hedging here a bit, but while it's easy to highlight the spark that Pringle gave the running game late in the season, it was Fletcher who was the steady reliable inside runner that this offense needs. He averaged just a shade under five yards a carry and had 10 touchdowns. As for Pringle, well, the offense just looked different (and more explosive) as he became a bigger part of the offense...

Honorable mention: Keelan Marion, Carter Davis, Markel Bell, Zechariah Poyser, CJ Daniels
Solid 1-7. Fletch and CJ would probably be top 10 for me personally.
 
So the #Canes regular season is over, they went 10-2 and earned a playoff bid. They play Texas A@M in Kyle Field next weekend. Here's one fans view of the top 10 players, not really just about stats but general impact and consistently good play throughout the year. I don't use PFF numbers or any analytics, again, just my overall view of all 12 games that I watched (and I literally saw every play of every game)

Again, I'm no expert, but just a guy who tunes into the games and formulates some opinions. Like pound-for-pound lists in boxing, this isn't to be taken all too seriously. Just a fun list to highlight those who have stood out for Miami in '25.

1- Malachi Toney: What else can be said? This true freshman is the most unique offensive weapon in UM history. We've seen triple-threats (receiving, running and kick/punt returns) at Miami, guys like Santana, Kevin Williams and Travis Benjamin, but Toney, is the rare quadruple-threat (his passing skills are QB-like). Should be in the Heisman discussion coming into next season. Toney just put up the greatest true freshman season in Miami history.

2- Ruben Bain : stats don't tell the whole story (4.5 sacks), Bain is a guy that elevates those around him as offenses game plan for him upfront. Biggest compliment I can pay him as that he could have played on any of the title winning teams in Miami's past.

3- Akheem Mesidor- If Bain is Crockett, then 'Mes' is 'Tubbs' and they formed the modern day 'Miami Vice'. These two might be the best overall Miami bookends edging out Kenard Lang/Kenny Holmes ,Jerome McDougle/Andrew Williams and Rusty Meaderis/Kevin Patrick and Darren Krein

4- Francis Mauignoa- since day one as a true freshman has held down the right tackle spot at a high level. He and Bain will leave Miami as first round draft choices.

5- Jakobe Thomas -- a physical enforcer who also showed he can play in space(led the team with 4 INT's). He and Z. Poyser upgraded Miami's safety play by leaps and bounds this season.

6- Keionte Scott- before his injury, 'Agent O' was in the contention for the Thorpe Award. His return would be huge in the playoffs

7- Carson Beck-- had some mid-season yips, but overall had a strong season, completing nearly 75-percent of his passes. Eventually developed strong chemistry (despite missing spring ball) with a relatively inexperienced set of receivers. Ultimately, his legacy will be in how far he can lead this team in the playoffs

8- Damari Brown - rarely did you hear his name called this season at corner. He is one of the reasons why this was the most improved aspect of the team. Really bounced back after an injury plagued '24 campaign

9- Ahmad Moten - made the leap late in the year from a reliable rotational piece to a guy who began to really become a standout inside the trenches. He is the very epitome of the 'player development' that Mario Cristobal speaks off.

10- Mark Fletcher/Girard Pringle -- Alright, Im hedging here a bit, but while it's easy to highlight the spark that Pringle gave the running game late in the season, it was Fletcher who was the steady reliable inside runner that this offense needs. He averaged just a shade under five yards a carry and had 10 touchdowns. As for Pringle, well, the offense just looked different (and more explosive) as he became a bigger part of the offense...

Honorable mention: Keelan Marion, Carter Davis, Markel Bell, Zechariah Poyser, CJ Daniels
Bryce Fitzgerald has been a great fill in as a freshman this year safety and also when he filled in for Keionte Scott. Fitzgerald has a bright future here as well. I know he didn't play enough to make top 10 but UM football has a bright future with a lot of promise.

Looking forward to Dec 20th! Go canes!
 
Advertisement
So the #Canes regular season is over, they went 10-2 and earned a playoff bid. They play Texas A@M in Kyle Field next weekend. Here's one fans view of the top 10 players, not really just about stats but general impact and consistently good play throughout the year. I don't use PFF numbers or any analytics, again, just my overall view of all 12 games that I watched (and I literally saw every play of every game)

Again, I'm no expert, but just a guy who tunes into the games and formulates some opinions. Like pound-for-pound lists in boxing, this isn't to be taken all too seriously. Just a fun list to highlight those who have stood out for Miami in '25.

1- Malachi Toney: What else can be said? This true freshman is the most unique offensive weapon in UM history. We've seen triple-threats (receiving, running and kick/punt returns) at Miami, guys like Santana, Kevin Williams and Travis Benjamin, but Toney, is the rare quadruple-threat (his passing skills are QB-like). Should be in the Heisman discussion coming into next season. Toney just put up the greatest true freshman season in Miami history.

2- Ruben Bain : stats don't tell the whole story (4.5 sacks), Bain is a guy that elevates those around him as offenses game plan for him upfront. Biggest compliment I can pay him as that he could have played on any of the title winning teams in Miami's past.

3- Akheem Mesidor- If Bain is Crockett, then 'Mes' is 'Tubbs' and they formed the modern day 'Miami Vice'. These two might be the best overall Miami bookends edging out Kenard Lang/Kenny Holmes ,Jerome McDougle/Andrew Williams and Rusty Meaderis/Kevin Patrick and Darren Krein

4- Francis Mauignoa- since day one as a true freshman has held down the right tackle spot at a high level. He and Bain will leave Miami as first round draft choices.

5- Jakobe Thomas -- a physical enforcer who also showed he can play in space(led the team with 4 INT's). He and Z. Poyser upgraded Miami's safety play by leaps and bounds this season.

6- Keionte Scott- before his injury, 'Agent O' was in the contention for the Thorpe Award. His return would be huge in the playoffs

7- Carson Beck-- had some mid-season yips, but overall had a strong season, completing nearly 75-percent of his passes. Eventually developed strong chemistry (despite missing spring ball) with a relatively inexperienced set of receivers. Ultimately, his legacy will be in how far he can lead this team in the playoffs

8- Damari Brown - rarely did you hear his name called this season at corner. He is one of the reasons why this was the most improved aspect of the team. Really bounced back after an injury plagued '24 campaign

9- Ahmad Moten - made the leap late in the year from a reliable rotational piece to a guy who began to really become a standout inside the trenches. He is the very epitome of the 'player development' that Mario Cristobal speaks off.

10- Mark Fletcher/Girard Pringle -- Alright, Im hedging here a bit, but while it's easy to highlight the spark that Pringle gave the running game late in the season, it was Fletcher who was the steady reliable inside runner that this offense needs. He averaged just a shade under five yards a carry and had 10 touchdowns. As for Pringle, well, the offense just looked different (and more explosive) as he became a bigger part of the offense...

Honorable mention: Keelan Marion, Carter Davis, Markel Bell, Zechariah Poyser, CJ Daniels
Good post Steve, I'll add a few more Honorable Mentions as I think the following players were very good in their roles.

Armando Blount
Marquis Lightfoot
David Blay
Justin Scott
Charmar Brown
Mo Toure
Bryce Fitzgerald
 
Good post Steve, I'll add a few more Honorable Mentions as I think the following players were very good in their roles.

Armando Blount
Marquis Lightfoot
David Blay
Justin Scott
Charmar Brown
Mo Toure
Bryce Fitzgerald
This guy has shown Jerome, Cortez, Sapp like flashes. His overall play has been solid. I think the light bulb has come on and he is just a sophomore.
 
So the #Canes regular season is over, they went 10-2 and earned a playoff bid. They play Texas A@M in Kyle Field next weekend. Here's one fans view of the top 10 players, not really just about stats but general impact and consistently good play throughout the year. I don't use PFF numbers or any analytics, again, just my overall view of all 12 games that I watched (and I literally saw every play of every game)

Again, I'm no expert, but just a guy who tunes into the games and formulates some opinions. Like pound-for-pound lists in boxing, this isn't to be taken all too seriously. Just a fun list to highlight those who have stood out for Miami in '25.

1- Malachi Toney: What else can be said? This true freshman is the most unique offensive weapon in UM history. We've seen triple-threats (receiving, running and kick/punt returns) at Miami, guys like Santana, Kevin Williams and Travis Benjamin, but Toney, is the rare quadruple-threat (his passing skills are QB-like). Should be in the Heisman discussion coming into next season. Toney just put up the greatest true freshman season in Miami history.

2- Ruben Bain : stats don't tell the whole story (4.5 sacks), Bain is a guy that elevates those around him as offenses game plan for him upfront. Biggest compliment I can pay him as that he could have played on any of the title winning teams in Miami's past.

3- Akheem Mesidor- If Bain is Crockett, then 'Mes' is 'Tubbs' and they formed the modern day 'Miami Vice'. These two might be the best overall Miami bookends edging out Kenard Lang/Kenny Holmes ,Jerome McDougle/Andrew Williams and Rusty Meaderis/Kevin Patrick and Darren Krein

4- Francis Mauignoa- since day one as a true freshman has held down the right tackle spot at a high level. He and Bain will leave Miami as first round draft choices.

5- Jakobe Thomas -- a physical enforcer who also showed he can play in space(led the team with 4 INT's). He and Z. Poyser upgraded Miami's safety play by leaps and bounds this season.

6- Keionte Scott- before his injury, 'Agent O' was in the contention for the Thorpe Award. His return would be huge in the playoffs

7- Carson Beck-- had some mid-season yips, but overall had a strong season, completing nearly 75-percent of his passes. Eventually developed strong chemistry (despite missing spring ball) with a relatively inexperienced set of receivers. Ultimately, his legacy will be in how far he can lead this team in the playoffs

8- Damari Brown - rarely did you hear his name called this season at corner. He is one of the reasons why this was the most improved aspect of the team. Really bounced back after an injury plagued '24 campaign

9- Ahmad Moten - made the leap late in the year from a reliable rotational piece to a guy who began to really become a standout inside the trenches. He is the very epitome of the 'player development' that Mario Cristobal speaks off.

10- Mark Fletcher/Girard Pringle -- Alright, Im hedging here a bit, but while it's easy to highlight the spark that Pringle gave the running game late in the season, it was Fletcher who was the steady reliable inside runner that this offense needs. He averaged just a shade under five yards a carry and had 10 touchdowns. As for Pringle, well, the offense just looked different (and more explosive) as he became a bigger part of the offense...

Honorable mention: Keelan Marion, Carter Davis, Markel Bell, Zechariah Poyser, CJ Daniels
Spot on top 10 list! Couldn’t have said it better myself.

Let’s Go Canes!!
 
Back
Top