We should be in the I formation as base offense. You can't expect it to function perfectly when the kids have been asked to use that formation only a fraction of the time. Last night we finally went to it early 4th quarter and gashed for something like 40 yards on two consecutive plays. Apparently that wasn't good enough. Instead of forcing Duke to stop it, we switched to our cupcake shotgun garbage.
On that final drive when we lined up in the I it looked reluctant and forced. The spacing wasn't ideal. That's always a tipoff. The old Student Body Right setup was tailback 7 yards deep. Gradually that has shifted to more like 8 yards deep. We were spaced too tight, with the linemen bunched and the fullback and tailback closer to the line of scrimmage than ideal. It was slightly less than 7 yards.
If that were our standard offense, or even a regular feature, we would know what we are doing, and have some wrinkles within the I to clear out congestion, even in a late game scenario like that.
On 3rd down we were stuck. It is long yardage. As a gambler I'd prefer to take a risk and throw it beyond the sticks. I didn't trust our defense to make a stand when it matters. A screen pass is a big favorite to get blown apart in the backfield, even though we did succeed with two 3rd down screens early in the game. I didn't mind that last throw except it needed to be a few yards deeper to allow more opportunity to bust tackles for a first down.