forums

Best of All Time

Advertisement
10.NATE WEBSTER
09.ED REED
08.ANDRE KING
07.JAMES JACKSON
06.BUBBA FRANKS
05.WILLIS MCGAHEE
04.ANDRE JOHNSON
03.REGGIE WAYNE
02.SEAN TAYLOR
01.SANTANA MOSS/DAN MORGAN.......MY 2 FAVORITE QB SCOTT COVINGTON AND KENN DORSEY
 
Ed Reed
Sean Taylor
Jerome Brown
Playmaker
Bennie Blades
Andre Johnson
Willis Mcgahee
Ray Lewis
Warren Sapp
Ken Dorsey
not putting them in any order
 
Last edited:
10. Graig Cooper

9. Roscoe Parrish

8. Antrelle Rolle

7. Vince Wilfork

6. Frank Gore

5. Clinton Portis

4. Ken Dorsey

3. Devin Hester

2. Willis McGahee

1. Ed Reed / Andre Johnson / Sean Taylor
 
10. Russell Maryland/
9. Michael Irvin
8. Stephen Mcguire/Ken Dorsey
7. Carlos Jones(that pick six is still my favorite pick six from the canes all time)
6. Sean Taylor
5. Ray Lewis
4. Andre Johnson/Portis
3. ed reed
2. edgerrin james
1. Santana Moss(his 99 season is why he is my favorite)

In that Order
 
Last edited by a moderator:
gacericardo said:
Graig Cooper? lmgdao
Click to expand...

Cooper was a good player for Miami and by the look of his list it seems like he is young. I mean it would be kinda stupid to put a list of your favorite Canes if you never watched them play.
 
Last edited:
An impossible task, there are so many greats. As an example, I did not see Ted Hendricks in any list above. He was probably the greatest of all -- 3 time AA and a one man destruction team. No to mention one crazy dude. Playmaker said Ted was all Cane before there was Cane. Plus, looks like both our Heisman QB winners missed the lists, and only one Outland winner made one list. Reed and ST, rip, show up nicely but Bennie Blades nowhere to be seen? Ed Brown? Kosar, Kelly, OJ, a host of Dlinemen .... and has anyone given two greater memories the Thrill Hill? The list goes on forever. We could have to go by decade to have any chance. Even that would be tough. We had great players before Howard got here. We just never had great coaches until Howard got here.
 
Advertisement
we had great players few were elite

Kosar
Hendricks
Willis Mchgahee
Dorsey
Sean T
Ed Reed
Ray Lewis
Bryant Mckinnie
Sapp
Brown

after that..we had great players
the last 10 years
Duke has that potential maybe Coley
 
Gamineal said:
we had great players few were elite

Kosar
Hendricks
Willis Mchgahee
Dorsey
Sean T
Ed Reed
Ray Lewis
Bryant Mckinnie
Sapp
Brown

after that..we had great players
the last 10 years
Duke has that potential maybe Coley
Click to expand...

That's a bogus list. I started following the team 3 years ago and I never heard of those guys.

[/sarcasm]
 
Gatorhater said:
An impossible task, there are so many greats. As an example, I did not see Ted Hendricks in any list above. He was probably the greatest of all -- 3 time AA and a one man destruction team. No to mention one crazy dude. Playmaker said Ted was all Cane before there was Cane. Plus, looks like both our Heisman QB winners missed the lists, and only one Outland winner made one list. Reed and ST, rip, show up nicely but Bennie Blades nowhere to be seen? Ed Brown? Kosar, Kelly, OJ, a host of Dlinemen .... and has anyone given two greater memories the Thrill Hill? The list goes on forever. We could have to go by decade to have any chance. Even that would be tough. We had great players before Howard got here. We just never had great coaches until Howard got here.
Click to expand...

Bennie was on mine
 
Micheal Irvin
Bernie Kosar
Ted Hendricks
Chuck Foreman
Ray Lewis
Sean Taylor
Ken Dorsey
Jerome Brown
Bennie Blades
Edgerrain James

Just missed
Otis Anderson
Ed Reed
Sanatana Moss
George Mira
Devin Hester
Frank Gore
Clinton Portis
ANdre Johnson
Willis Mcgahee
Reggie Wayne
Gino Torretta
Steve Walsh
Jim Kelly
Winston Moss
 
Last edited:
So many great players. Not going to put a top ten, but I'll give you the most important player in canes history: Jim Kelly
 
Advertisement
gacericardo said:
BucCANEers said:
gacericardo said:
Graig Cooper? lmgdao
Click to expand...

Cooper was a good player for Miami and by the look of his list it seems like he is young. I mean it would be kinda stupid to put a list of your favorite Canes if you never watched them play.
Click to expand...

I must be mistaken then If this a top ten favorite list but graig cooper wouldn't crack the top 100 players In Miami history
Click to expand...

He didn't say rank the top ten best players of all time did he? I think he said rank your favorites. I remember Graig coming onto the scene as a freshman on a Thursday night game and playing huge. It sucks he tore his ACL. He would have been good in the league. He made plays here. I always loved seeing him play.

I am in my early twenty's. I could put Michael Irvin there but I never saw him play at The U, I wasn't born.
 
Last edited:
wvcanefan said:
Gatorhater said:
An impossible task, there are so many greats. As an example, I did not see Ted Hendricks in any list above. He was probably the greatest of all -- 3 time AA and a one man destruction team. No to mention one crazy dude. Playmaker said Ted was all Cane before there was Cane. Plus, looks like both our Heisman QB winners missed the lists, and only one Outland winner made one list. Reed and ST, rip, show up nicely but Bennie Blades nowhere to be seen? Ed Brown? Kosar, Kelly, OJ, a host of Dlinemen .... and has anyone given two greater memories the Thrill Hill? The list goes on forever. We could have to go by decade to have any chance. Even that would be tough. We had great players before Howard got here. We just never had great coaches until Howard got here.
Click to expand...

Bennie was on mine
Click to expand...

Sorry, I missed him. We had another safety a few years before and I cannot remember his name. Real smart, like a coach back there. I think he went 1st round to Pats, not sure. Getting old and names are slipping away.
 
wherrera8 said:
gacericardo said:
BucCANEers said:
gacericardo said:
Graig Cooper? lmgdao
Click to expand...

Cooper was a good player for Miami and by the look of his list it seems like he is young. I mean it would be kinda stupid to put a list of your favorite Canes if you never watched them play.
Click to expand...

I must be mistaken then If this a top ten favorite list but graig cooper wouldn't crack the top 100 players In Miami history
Click to expand...

He didn't say rank the top ten best players of all time did he? I think he said rank your favorites. I remember Graig coming onto the scene as a freshman on a Thursday night game and playing huge. It sucks he tore his ACL. He would have been good in the league. He made plays here. I always loved seeing him play.

I am in my early twenty's. I could put Michael Irvin there but I never saw him play at The U, I wasn't born.
Click to expand...

He didn't say anything about favorites. He said best of all time.
 
Back
Top