Just look at the catch itself, the stage it happened on, the opponent, the moment in the game, and the degree of difficulty. Every factor that goes into what makes a catch one of the greatest catches ever is there.
I know it didn't count, but honestly, that doesn't even matter when you're talking about the catch itself.
Malachi Toney somehow tracks the ball, adjusts in midair, and finishes it with ridiculous body control. It's one of those plays that gets more impressive every time you watch it. The first time you see it, you're shocked. The second and third time, you start appreciating just how absurd it really was.
Enjoy the clip and watch it a few more times. As far as pure catches go, this is one of the best I've ever seen.