Search results

Bengals fans disagree

This is a very stand up thing to do. I'll make a donation and PM you the receipt

I have to say you're right, I'm way too critical Walton. He's a better player and will improve as he gains confidence from what he's showing right now. I can see a scenario where things fall right and he fills a pass receiving/special teams niche for a team. I just have a hard time seeing him...

Fair enough. I'll stick with my Matt Dayes comparison. Time will tell

Your post is a perfect example of what my problem people's opinion of Walton will always be - so much is wrong, or just ignored because of 1 big game or 1 big play. No question he had a great game against NC St. So 1 great game means you should ignore that in his Soph year he only averaged...

I understand the hate for Scarlett. He's a Gator and he played us in recruiting. Walton has always been all Miami. I get it. I don't think Scarlett is some superstar - I just think if you objectively look at what they did vs. P5 competition, it's hard to make the case for Walton being better...

I can see the off field stuff playing a factor on their draft position. I don't necessarily think Williams & Scarlett will be drafted higher than Walton - I just think their significantly better numbers vs. P5 teams and athletic testing, and running style makes them better prospects. I also...

I agree you on 1 & 3. On 2 - I'd rank them Williams, Scarlett, Walton - but can definitely see ranking those 3 in any order in terms of their college production. I do think Williams and Scarlett will test much better athletically than Walton, which tips the scale to them in terms of being...

So No, No, and No?

I'll definitely pay - no problem. @ssvir & @OriginalCanesCanesCanes - just PM how you want to get paid and I'll get you your $100 But looking at some career numbers, and checking back in on the Walton discussion, I've got some questions for you Walton vs. ACC - 230 att 949 yds 4.1 ypc 9...

A JAG is really all he needed to be to catch Walton. 182 for 936 yds 5.1 ypc - that's it. Scarlett certainly doesn't need to be anything special, he just needs to get the carries.

Only 19 carries is the key stat. Looks like UF might be a RBC and Scarlett won't get the volume to catch Walton. The Walton side of the bet is looking pretty good right now. And Homer vs. Akers isn't looking so pretty either.

Done. Yeah, if Scarlett gets suspended again then that's definitely a loss for me.

Except Yearby always had the better average: 2015 - Walton 3.5 Yearby 4.9 2016 - Walton 5.3 Yearby 6.0 2 things i'll never understand: 1) Why people defend Walton to the death 2) Why NFL teams keep paying Sam Bradford to be their starting QB

I said Yearby, Walton & Gus were all similar talent levels. I thought Yearby was outplaying Walton in 2016 and should've been given more carries (instead he lost his carries to Gus) Here's our first 4 ACC games in 2016 that made me think that: Yearby only got 29 carries over the next 6...

I agree that Walton has put up better numbers in college, to this point. And the end of this year, that might be different. Nick Chubb, Ronald Jones, Derrius Guice, Kerryon Johnson were 2nd round picks this year. I don't think Walton is in their category. (although I think Johnson was also...

That's my point - Scarlett rushing for the same or better yards as Walton "isn't a big ask". So why do you say Walton is 10 times the football player than Scarlett? Walton vs Scarlett is a legitimate discussion - I've said before, it's close and I can totally see how someone would prefer...

I'll give you $100 too. Scarlett tops 936 yards, I win. If he gets injured, bets off. You good with that, or do you need the injury cushion like Original?

Sorry, I said don't think of Walton is a sexual scenario. I should've said don't think of ANY dude in a sexual scenario. My bad - that one's on me. I'll take the bet, injury or not. Scarlett just needs to top 936 yds. Want to put $100 on it to make it more interesting?

Take a deep breath.... Now try not to think of Walton in some type of sexual scenario..... Are you willing to take the bet?