Search results

No, but I get the hyperbole. McKinnie could have been a HOF player. Chose to be much, much less.

Some people settle for less than the best.

Jon Ogden (4th overall pick) played 12 seasons: 11 Pro Bowls, 4x 1st team All-Pro, 5x 2nd team All-Pro, NFL 2000s All-Decade team. McKinnie (7th overall) had the talent to have a similar career. So, yes, I consider him a bust.

I hear ya. McKinney should have had a HOF career like Johnathan Ogden. But yeah, Rumph was a total bust. He didn't make a lot of big plays in college. I don't know what NFL teams saw to take him first round.

Good question. Rumph and Flowers were overrated by NFL scouts. Based on expectations McKinney was a bigger bust. I remember how he abused Dwight Freeney in 2001. He may have played and made some money, but he could have been a HOF player.