There were just as many Butch haters while he was actually the head coach. No one wants to admit to being involved in the "Botch" and "Freckles" days of Grassy.
It's very simple. If you're going to make the claim that Butch can repeat what he did from 1998-2000, why hasn't he repeated it? That is a valid question, because if he can't repeat it, what makes him the best candidate?
That's just another deflection. You guys make the claim that Butch would repeat what he did before. If he could do what he did before, why hasn't he done it? It has been 19 years.