I like your five, but would you not flip St Louis and Scaife around? Seems if Scaife is the more athletic / mobile player, he's the one you want on the blindside.
In their defence, I don't think Donaldson is an OT and St Louis is a marginal RT.
Jones shouldn't really see the field. Gauthier is the one that worries me - he keeps getting beat in these games. We're not even in ACC play yet.