This reminds me of the "If Scott Covington had been the QB all along and not Ryan Clement would we have been better from 95-97" argument from back in 1998. That was a helluva argument in those days. Scott had us all looking at Ryan kind of sideways after that 98' season. That said, everything...
Lets revisit this after the Pitt game. If TVD pulls that win out I am all for having this discussion because its a VERY legit question at that point. Because the rest of the schedule are absolutely games that are winnable. (GT, VT, FSU, Duke)