if Manning, Rogers, Brees, Montana, and Marino were on the dolphins he'd have 0 superbowls and likely be retired already due to injury. how does that make him the Goat if he would be awful on any other team?
I would say the Browns would be exponentially better with Brady than without Brady. Unless you've played some QB it is hard to truly appreciate how the offense if good because of him. He makes the running game successful by deciding when and where to run the ball with his presnap reads. Sure...
So.....based on your argument, which quarterback Is better that Brady?
You must be young not to know about Montana or Elway.
And I disagree about your basketball analysis. Because there are only 5 players playing having good players on your team affects the outcome of a team much more than...
Fixed above.
Seriously though, this line of thinking really undermines greatness. Would Jordan be great without Pippen? Or Phil Jackson? The Bulls went to the playoffs when Jordan left for baseball. So they were a pretty good team without him.
Does Elway win a Super Bowl without T. Davis...
Name me one quarterback better than Brady that you could drop onto the Browns and have 9 Super Bowl visits and I'll hang up and listen (and have a good laugh).