Search results

You're the one initiating the insults here, but I'm the '2000 post mouthbreather' because I don't go along with your over-stated argument. Not surprised you're retreating. Or hiding yourself from the consequences of your meltdown. And here I'd thought you were a real poster.

Great. So your theory is if only we had Lincoln Riley and Vince Young, we wouldn't need a QB who can read defenses. I guess we can agree, but I think your perspective is irrelevant to our real world priorities and needs.

1. I’m not interested in the nfl, just success at Miami 2. Plenty of drafted QBs don’t pan out in the nfl anyhow 3. Not all highly drafted qbs are great college QBs 4. Processing the D, feeling the pocket, and making good decisions under pressure are really valuable attributes of good QBs...

The discussion here is lacking as far as evals of this kid go. High school record doesn’t project a kid to be a starting QB for a major program. The ability of people to just talk by each other on this topic is weird. He’s a great athlete, prototype size, good arm, good leader. Those are...

Richt didn't recruit Crow. He was a Golden special. Maybe you're referring to Sit? The links you responded to were of Crow. As for Richt/Sit, yes, I lost any confidence I had in his QB evals with Sit. IMO he had checked out and was more interested in supporting his son's evals than in doing...

Okay, you're in denial or being intentionally obtuse. You're getting your panties wet because of a comparison. Comparisons identify similarities. They're not predictions that they'll end up similarly. They do shed light on what the key bets you're making are. What will cause them to be...

You all are trying too hard to convince yourself there’s no comparison. There’s an obvious comparison. They’re both prototype athletes, sit more the pro style prototype amd Brown a duel-threat ine. Both 6-4, 205+ heading into senior summer. Both need work at the qb spot. Brown pretty...

You’re changing your argument and trying to switch to you’re an evaluator, which isn’t the point or issue. I was clear I didn’t like the Sit eval back when we took his commitment. And I’m on record as liking taking Brown’s commitment. But that’s neither here nor there. Because you and me...

The idea that it’s a defense of a prospect that he has not had a private QB coach sounds logically odd. You know how many kids fit that bucket? We take one QB a year. Maybe you’re giving a reason why we shouldn’t have talen Sit’s commitment. You aren’t giving a reaskn why this kid will be...

Feel free to respond with facts and logic.

I’m all for taking a chance in this kid because of his athletic upside. But I don’t understand tie arguments around him. If you’re recruiting a QB, it matters a lot if he can play QB. Lotta folks here almost claiming just grab anyone, blah ...what? It’s not a mark of anything good that he's...

LMAO. Look, I was not up on sotkowski, but your response is crazy. This time that year sit hasn’t even committed, let alone been dropped. I like Brown as a prospect more than Sit - but the idea there’s no comparison. you’re just flat out wrong. Brown hasn’t been fully evaluated. that is...

I half agree but see it a bit differently. He has much higher upside than Crow or Allison, obviously. However, what attracts me is his _downside_ is much higher, too. Not because he can't fail as a QB, but because, if he does, he still projects as a top athlete at several other positions...