Search results

Man now Ive watched his film, really want this kid. Looks right there to me with the top two DEs. Reminded me of Danny Stubbs the way he threw that QB down in one of them clips.

I remember you being high on chatfield. and honestly, i didn't have anything other than a gut feeling to lose confidence in him as a prospect. he just seemed like a tweener. and there was something weird about him in the interviews and in his recruitment if i recall correctly. like he...

he came here as a dl. i think it was simpson not kul - kul was garvin. GR didn't switch positions after getting here. chatfield was an interesting kid. I got caught up in thinking early on we should offer him because he had some real supporters in the fan base but tbh as the senior year...

Hmm. I don’t see his name on a lot of those guys so didn’t realize he deserved credit for them. Kudos to him if so. Get us bissainthe.

Excited to see kelly as a senior. Hope we can turn him. re fields, i definitely am referring to his broader recruiting. Not complaining abojt te but see him as a guy who’s supposed to do the pied piper thing. Maybe hartley got too much credit but te coach is the spot for the true recruiters...

Good for manny in tjat case. Like to hear that.

i don’t have anything for rumph. despite what you think i was probably one of the very first people here to say he should be fired because he couldn’t recruit - back early in the richt years. but i didn’t go from that to blaming him for more than he deserves or building others up beyond what...

You got a thing for rumph. okay. doesn’t matter either way to me. simpson is solid. we’ll see in fields. would like to see more in recruiting from him but not complaining. As for manny and rousseau, if that’s true, good for manny. didn’t recall that. best news i’ve heard about manny as...

No idea why you’d respond with that to me. Where have I ever said Alabama develops kids better? Probably nowhere. They recruit and evaluate really well, and have a good enough culture and environment that kids can compete and improve (and hence develop). They do get really good coaches, but...

So you now give manny the credit for ‘developing’ our DEs? Okay. Too bad he couldn’t develop any LBs he recruited when he actually recruited and coached LBs. The point on simpson and field is clear enough. you were dissing rumph as a HS coach. rumph did a lot more on the field than either...

Lmao. nice logic Of course it does. Except, the coaches pick them. That’s why we talk about evaluations. As for Richards and Pope, I definitely want one of the richards skeptics. Don’t recall them like you do but will take your word for it. I did think pope would be better than he is...

See, this makes no sense to me. We've had 3 different DL coaches the past 5 years, and 2 different TE coaches. Neither of the TE coaches were known as developers. Simpson came here from HS. Fields wasn't far from it. It ain't some magic coaching we're giving them. And the S&C room ain't...

You're seeing ghosts, man. Double standard? Do you blame our same staff for not 'developing' Donaldson or Scaife? Or Mallory to this point? Or Pope? You guys want to hand out green stars for every success and sweep every failure under the carpet. I'm just tryna be balanced. We ain't good...

Lingard is who he is. He wasn't any better here than there. He was a bad EVALUATION. You can try to tell me that Phillips was a bad evaluation coming out of HS but no one will believe it. He was a top prospect who had injury issues, left the game for a year, then got back into it. Re...

You're trying too hard with me man. Not sure what you're even responding to. I simply responded to a poster denigrating what Phillips was before he got here as if he was some magical creation of UM. He was the top recruit in the country, and obviously lost size after stopping playing for a...

Phillips was the No.1 prospect in the country his senior year of HS.

One kid we recruited, played one year, didn’t even start the beginning of the year. Two other transfers. Not sure it’s as obvious as it sounds.