Search results

Bo isn’t in. Neither is Sterling Sharpe. And there are no specialists in other than Ray Guy, iirc.

Yes but the comparison I responded to was re hester, who didn’t play for a zillion years and isn’t top 10 all time in points scored. Gore will get in because longevity. It happens.

Yeah after reed, monk, lofton and bruce got it, AJ and Wayne have to grt it.

You’re the one trying too hard. First team all decade was just some hype thing the nfl did. Covert had 2 pro bowls, 1 superbowl. Nfw he makes it if not ‘da bears.’ andre reed retired in 2000. He was elected in 2014. Almost missed the cutoff. Not 5th all time in 2014. His career...

Read more closely. You’re narrowing to DL. Not what I wrote. Swann and Stallworth wouldn’t be jn the HOF without the dynasty. For that matter, Richard Dent and Dan Hampton and Jimbo Covert wouldn’t be there without the Bears legendary teams, either. Andre Reed wouldn’t without the Bills...

Not sure you’re saying much different from me as far as data but i don’t think you sufficiently appreciate the sognifance of guys who anchored units on dynasties / top teams when it comes to HOF voting. It’s a huge criterion. Vince is respected amongst his peers in a way your stats don’t...

Vince’s resume isn’t like those guys. His resume is anchor of dynasty DL in the middle, 2 SBs. More pro bowls than them too. He could get in. His peers know what he was. I put it below 50% but >25%. Real chance.

I hope he makes it. There just is no precedence for a returner making it.

Hester never kicked a field goal? In all seriousness, Stenarud retired top 10 all time in points scored.

IMO Dre > Wayne on merits unless it’s the SB. Andre was 3x first team all pro to 1x for wayne, more pro bowls, led league in receiving 2x to 2x for wayne. comparable yards. worse everything around him. IMO Both receivers 1a/1b, then Vince (best NT of his era and multiple SBs but low stats)...