I hesitated to say Hester because he played two seasons and the first one he was good but still raw. I also think Kevin Williams had a good two year run at returner so I put him ahead barely.
NFL career for Hester was out of this world though.
Reed on Defense.
Maybe Edge on Offense. Special shout out to OJ Anderson who had a good College career before the U became very good and had a solid NFL career (Super Bowl MVP).
Special Teams Jeff Feagles.