Search results

Tom Brady is the greatest QB of all time. Roethlisberger is a Hall of Famer. Rivers and Ryan never won a Super Bowl...if they did, they'd be Hall of Famers, too. Winning matters. Sorry. Also, ANY/A isn't a longevity number. Its an era adjusted figure.

He's 4th among his contemporaries in pass yards and touchdowns. If you go by adjusted numbers, he's got an ANY/A right next to Favre, higher than Kelly, Fouts, Moon, Aikman, Elway. He's got the numbers - both raw and era edjusted, the Super Bowls...I am not sure what else you're looking for.

If you think that, you'd be getting rid of half of the modern era QBs that are already in the Hall of Fame. C'mon now. Your criteria just doesn't align with the reality of his career.

You're complicating an easy equation. Top 10 passer at the completion of his career and two Super Bowl wins with MVPs attached. Its really that simple. The Hall of Fame has guys like Moon, Warner, Aikman, and Kelly in it. Of course Eli is a Hall of Famer. Looking at the Top 25 passers in...

Hall of Famer...its not even debatable.