You can say that, it is all hypothetical, so it really is a pointless conversation. I still stand by what I said though, PSU has played 3 teams with a pulse, and went 0-3.
I get your point but lets be honest, PSU is not a top 10 team. They have played 3 good teams this year and guess what, got dominated in all 3. They were top 10 because they beat up on an extremely bad big 10.