Search results

Anybody want to bet on the FSU/Georgia game? I’ll take Georgia but you have to give me at least 3 points since FSU is one of the four best teams in the country and Georgia isn’t.

It’s been listed by multiple posters in this thread. One part of the criteria is to weigh injured players and how they can effect games. If your starting quarterback misses a game and your team doesn’t play well, they weigh that. If your team loses it’s starting quarterback and is significantly...

The committee’s job is to pick the four best teams, not reward four teams for a successful season. It’s literally in the criteria.

Solid point. I definitely think seeing FSU’s offense without Travis the last two weeks influenced the decision. There’s always an “unknown” factor with a new quarterback. “Maybe he’s good? Maybe there won’t be a drop off?” But after watching QB2 and QB 3 play for the Noles, it’s pretty obvious...

Exact same scenario we’re in today. Washington is the undefeated PAC12 champ but their Heisman candidate quarterback who carried them all year is out with no shot at playing. Are they one of the four best teams? Do they keep UGA out?

I don’t care if they play tomorrow, next week or next month. Alabama and FSU play 10 times with no Jordan Travis and Alabama wins at least 9 times. A healthy Washington team plays a healthy UGA team 10 times and the results are likely much closer. By the way, you seem to think UGA is better...

If Alabama plays FSU tomorrow, who wins?

If Penix tore a knee ligament against Oregon, would Washington be in?

The criteria has ALWAYS been the four best teams. Not the four most deserving teams. Also TCU beat Michigan so your point is moot. FSU isn’t good enough to beat any of the teams in the top 4 without their quarterback. How anyone outside of FSU fans could honestly look at all the teams and...

To me, it’s 100% the Travis injury. It’s got nothing to do with the ACC or their schedule or anything else.

So explain how you think that FSU can beat Michigan, Washington Alabama or Texas? I’m not talking about beating Louisville who literally just lost to 7-5 Kentucky a week ago. I’m talking about beating one of the four best teams. FSU will have their shot to prove the committee wrong anyway. If...

First of all. **** FSU. Secondly, the committee did EXACTLY what they were supposed to do. You’re supposed to pick the four best teams, not the four most deserving teams. Injuries to key players are supposed to be taken into account. Nowhere does the guidelines say “an undefeated P5 conference...