Search results

  1. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    yeah those two were really bad against the run. But Gauthier struggled at times too. McDermott was pretty consistent and did well against the pass rush. Donaldson got beat a few times, but when you remember he was just a ******* true frosh, oh boy. I hope Donaldson wins the starting RT job. Give...
  2. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    The OL was a big factor too. But they did pretty well pass blocking. It was run blocking that was the problem last year. This year we're losing our weakest link on the OL - Darling. WE ******* better hope Tyree St Louis steps his *** up in the run blocking deparment. He was bad at it last year...
  3. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    lol, I did that with you in mind haha
  4. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    Last thing, Why on earth should the tie go to Rosier? Like Actually why should he be the default starter? Going with Rosier is like taking $5 out of your wallet and just throwing it in the trash, while going with one of the freshman is like Spending that $5 on a ******* Scratcher at the gas...
  5. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    Ight I'm completely done with this. I'll post this for anyone that would like to see for themselves just how ******* bad Rosier was ESPECIALLY in the 5 most important games. Then remember that doesn't even include the 2 games he got benched - UNC and Pitt. Then ask yourself is this something...
  6. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    ROSIER AS A ******* PASSER YOU ******* IDIOT. holy **** dude. are you really this thick right now? haha Im pretty sure I've never said Rosier was a bad runner. Not great but definitely not bad.
  7. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    No it doesn't count. That should have been an easy win. Did you want me to include UNC and GTech too because we almost lost to them due to you're butt buddy being a **** qb? Pitt isn't even close to the quality opponent the 5 I'm using are. And If i did use pitt it would just make Rosier look...
  8. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    bruh Rosier had a ******* sub 50% comp % in over half our ******* games. lol. You're sitting here talking about it not being important to get to 60%, meanwhile Rosier can't even ******* get to 50%! Secondly Idgaf what someones completion percentage was pre 2ks and when the passing game started...
  9. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    We didn't average 119 ypg or less. In those 5 games we averaged 162 ypg. Maybe you don't know this but our offense does involve the rpo. I think 160 yards rushing per game between the RB and QB IN OUR BIG GAMES is enough to win a championship IF our QB is not enept, yes. ...but I think our...
  10. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    maybe hes commenting on my little quick charts because you have had absolutely no response to them. Its like you don't want to believe the objective numbers I'm giving. And you're acting like the ONLY thing Rosier was bad at was Comp%, but thats not true. Secondly you're acting like a low Comp%...
  11. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    1) Walton only played in one game that I have listed - FSU. In that game Homer only got 3 carries and Dallas got 0. In the other 4 games only Homer and Deejay had any carries. So no, I'm not actually comparing the work of 3 RBs in a game to one. 2) Carries per game (I should have listed this on...
  12. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    https://gyazo.com/00989b52f9b60540129baf0ac84ef9cf
  13. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    https://gyazo.com/0cc23aa4fbfdc6b4d1e6f1444e9adbda Homer and Dallas actually played well in our biggest games, as you can see by their Y/C being above 6. So literally Homer and Dallas played well while our QB played like ***
  14. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    You're an idiot. You know why Dorsey wasn't sacked? Because if teams were going to blitz on him he could identify it and knew where to go with the ball. Rosier DOES NOT KNOW THIS! Rosier the minute he sensed pressure, brings his eyes down and tries to scramble. A good Qb will get it to his...
  15. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    He started off with like 3 carries for like 11 yards. in the first half (which was the half that paragraph was about). Every single bad run he had I swear to god the OL just let 2+ guys get to Homer practically untouched. Point is it wasn't on the RBs why the run game was bad. Even if homer...
  16. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    Small little breakdown: 1st of all Ahmmon, Herndon, Berrios, and Thomas were ALL playing in this game - at least to start. Homer got 7 carries for 12 yards. While he wasn't hitting big runs, most of them were decent gains. In the first half he barely got any carries and except for one 3rd down...
  17. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    What you're asking is everyone to essentially just watch the tape and subjectively grade Rosiers performance. Thats great an all, but you have two people watch a play and they are going to give 2 completely different grades. Thats why PFF is flawed, ultimately they are just making subjective...
  18. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    So you're literally defending him this much because Rosier, a 5th yr senior, has a better understanding of the playbook 2 weeks before Spring practice is even over. ok. What do you think Rosiers floor/ceiling is this season? and what do you think the freshmans floor/ceiling is? Personally I...
  19. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    okay how about this. meeting in the middle, I believe this would have to be universally agreed to: 1. Start Rosier vs LSU. If he sucks, pull him and we rock with the freshman the rest of the game. If we win, it still does not lock Rosier into the starting job. Ultimatley in the long run, This...
  20. calinative umstudent

    Scrimmage take...

    funny since you still have yet to give ANY argument to combat my chart showing Rosiers passing stats vs our 5 most important games of the season - FSU, VTech, ND, Clemson, and ND. And thats not even including 2 games he got ******* pulled in - UNC and Pitt. This is our 2018 schedule: 1. LSU...
Back
Top