2004 or 2014: Which Roster has more Talent?

CyberCane

Junior
Joined
Nov 10, 2011
Messages
1,516
I'm obviously not counting what some of the 2004 guys went on to do in the NFL (for example I think Beason was a better NFL player).

2004:

1 Roscoe Parrish WR 5-9 170 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Senior HS)
2 Jon Beason LB 6-1 220 Unk Miramar, Fla. (Chaminade-Madonna Prep)
3 Frank Gore RB 5-10 220 Jr. Coral Gables, Fla. (Coral Gables Senior HS)
4 Devin Hester WR 5-11 185 So. Riviera Beach (Suncoast HS)
5 Greg Threat S 6-2 195 Jr. Tallahassee, Fla. (Lincoln HS)
6 Antrel Rolle CB 6-1 202 Sr. Homestead, Fla. (South Dade Senior HS)
7 Brock Berlin QB 6-1 215 Sr. Shreveport, La. (Evangel Christian Academy)
8 Darnell Jenkins WR 5-10 185 So. Miami, Fla. (Central HS)
9 Lance Leggett WR 6-3 180 Fr. Bartow, Fla. (Arlington (Texas) Grace Prep)
11 Matt Carter H 6-4 215 Sr. Columbus, Ohio. (Columbus Academy)
12 Kirby Freeman QB 6-3 195 Fr. Brownwood, Texas (Brownwood HS)
13 Jon Peattie K 6-3 210 So. Clearwater, Fla. (Countryside HS)
15 Buck Ortiega TE 6-5 225 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Gulliver Prep HS)
16 Kyle Wright QB 6-5 210 Unk Danville, Calif. (Monte Vista HS)
17 Willie Williams LB 6-2 230 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Carol City HS)
18 Derrick Crudup QB 6-1 215 Sr. Deerfield Beach, FL (Deerfield Beach HS)
19 Brandon Meriweather S 6-1 185 So. Apopka, Fla. (Apopka HS)
20 Terrell Walden CB 6-0 170 Unk Miami, Fla. (Edison HS)
21 Travarous Bain CB 6-0 175 So. Miami, Fla. (Northwestern HS)
22 Kelly Jennings CB 6-0 175 Jr. Live Oak (Suwannee HS)
23 Quadtrine Hill FB 6-2 225 Jr. Sunrise (Piper HS)
24 Marcus Maxey S 6-3 195 Jr. Navasota, Texas (Navasota HS)
25 Bobby Washington RB 6-1 200 Fr. Miami, Fla./Killian (Killian HS)
26 Anthony Reddick S 6-1 190 Fr. Ft. Lauderdale, Fla. (St. Thomas Aquinas HS)
27 Carlos Armour CB 6-3 200 Fr. Memphis, Tenn (Melrose HS)
27 Joe Tolliver DB 6-1 185 RFr. Miramar, Fla. (Dr. Krop HS)
28 Willie Cooper S 6-1 205 Unk St. Augustine (St. Augustine HS)
29 Tanard Davis CB 6-0 185 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Southridge HS)
30 Tyrone Moss RB 5-10 210 So. Pompano Beach, Fla. (Blanche Ely HS)
31 Glenn Sharpe CB 5-11 181 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Carol City HS)
32 Andrew Johnson TB 5-11 195 Fr. Pittsburgh, Pa. (North Hills SHS)
32 Jeff Malley RB 6-1 185 Jr. St. Petersburg, Fla. (Shorecrest Prep)
33 Mark Gent K 6-1 210 Jr. Ft. Lauderdale, Fla. (St. Thomas Aquinas)
34 Charlie Jones RB 5-11 200 Fr. Homestead, Fla. (South Dade Senior HS)
35 Lavon Ponder S 6-0 218 RFr. Miami, Fla. (Monsignor Pace HS)
36 Derron Thomas RB 5-11 190 Fr. Reserve, La. (East Saint John HS)
37 George Timmons DB 6-0 175 Fr. Lake City (Columbia HS)
38 Rashaun Jones WR 6-1 180 Fr. Lake City, Fla. (Columbia High School- South)
39 Brian Monroe P 6-2 200 So. Palm Beach Gardens (Palm Beach Gardens HS)
40 Kyle Cobia FB 6-2 235 Sr. Lakeland, Fla. (Lakeland Senior HS)
41 Talib Humphrey FB 6-2 250 Sr. Miami, Fla. (Oklahoma JC) (Southridge HS)
43 Francesco Zampogna K/P 5-9 207 So. Naples, Fla. (Naples HS)
44 Leon Williams LB 6-4 240 Jr. Brooklyn, N.Y. (Canarsie HS)
45 James Bryant LB 6-3 240 Fr. Reading, Pa. (Reading HS)
46 Grant Brown P/K 6-3 192 RFr. North Versailles, Pa. (East Allegheny HS)
46 Jean Volcy RB 5-10 220 Jr. North Miami Beach (North Miami Beach HS)
47 Vegas Franklin DE 6-3 240 Unk Reserve, La. (East St. John HS)
48 Stanley Pasley WR 6-2 212 So. Hemingway, S.C. (Hemingway HS)
49 Kurt Stange TE 6-5 211 Jr. Chippewa Falls, Wisc. (Chippewa Falls HS)
50 Rocky McIntosh LB 6-3 235 Jr. Gaffney, S.C. (Gaffney HS)
50 McIntosh Roger LB 6-2 231 Jr. Gaffney, S.C. (Gaffney HS)
51 Romeo Davis LB 6-3 200 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Northwestern HS)
52 Tavares Gooden LB 6-1 220 So. Ft. Lauderdale, Fla. (St. Thomas Aquinas)
53 Chris Zellner DE 6-3 225 Fr. Sarasota, Fla. (Booker HS)
54 Teraz McCray DT 6-0 285 Unk Pompano Beach (Ely HS)
55 Glenn Cook LB 6-1 225 Unk Hollywood, Fla. (Chaminade-Madonna Prep)
56 Santonio Thomas DT 6-4 305 Sr. South Bay, Fla. (Glades Central HS)
57 Javon Nanton DE 6-3 240 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Springs HS)
58 Kris Smith LB 5-10 190 Sr. Dallas, Texas (Rowlett HS)
59 Brad Kunz OL 6-7 315 Sr. Carlyle, Ill. (Carlyle HS)
60 Jonathan St.-Pierre OL 6-3 315 Fr. Longueuil, QC (Edouard Montpetit HS)
61 Tony Tella OL 6-5 300 Jr. Houston, Texas (Madison HS)
63 Alex Pou OL 6-4 280 So. Coral Gables, Fla. (Coral Gables HS)
64 Rashad Butler OL 6-5 290 Jr. Palm Beach Gardens (Dwyer HS)
65 Alex Garcia OL 6-1 290 Sr. Miami, Fla. (Christopher Columbus HS)
66 Chris Napoli OL 6-3 285 So. Davie, Fla. (St. Thomas Aquinas HS)
66 John Rochford OL 6-3 295 Unk Linewood,N.J. (Mainland Regional HS)
67 Tyrone Byrd OL 6-5 260 Fr. Sugar Land, Texas (Houston Hightower HS)
68 Adam Bates OL 6-1 275 RFr. Edmond, Okla. (Deer Creek HS)
68 Tyler McMeans OL 6-5 340 Jr. Shippenville, Pa. (Lackawanna JC) (Clarion HS)
69 Pedro Marti DL 6-2 275 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Columbus HS)
70 Joel Rodriguez OL 6-3 285 Sr. Miami, Fla. (Monsignor Pace HS)
71 Derrick Morse OL 6-5 325 Unk Fort Myers, Fla. (Estero HS)
72 Andrew Bain OL 6-3 340 Unk Pompano Beach, Fla. (Blanche Ely HS)
73 Cyrim Wimbs OL 6-4 325 Unk Pompano Beach (Ely HS)
74 Eric Winston OL 6-75 315 Jr. Midland, Texas (Lee HS)
75 Kellen Heard DL 6-6 335 Fr. Wharton, Texas (Wharton HS)
76 Chris Rutledge OL 6-7 280 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Dr. Krop HS)
77 Chris Myers OL 6-5 300 Sr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Palmetto Senior HS)
78 Anthony Wollschlager OL 6-6 305 So. Ft. Lauderdale, Fla. (St. Thomas Aquinas HS)
79 Robert Bergman OL 6-5 285 Jr. Bakersfield, Calif. (Bakersfield HS)
80 Akieem Jolla WR 6-4 190 Unk New Orleans, La. (St. Augustine HS)
81 Calais Campbell DE 6-7 230 Fr. Aurora, Colo. (South HS)
82 Greg Olsen TE 6-6 250 Unk Wayne, N.J. (Wayne Hills HS)
83 Sinorice Moss WR 5-8 180 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Carol City HS)
84 Kevin Everett TE 6-5 250 Sr. Port Arthur, Texas (Jefferson HS)
85 Ryan Moore WR 6-3 215 So. Orlando, Fla. (Dr. Phillips HS)
86 Brandon Sebald TE 6-6 255 Jr. Accord, N.Y. (Rondout Valley HS)
87 Dave Howell DT 6-4 296 Unk Royal Palm Beach (Royal Palm Beach HS)
87 Khalil Jones WR 6-2 210 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Northwestern HS)
88 Curtis Justus LS 6-6 218 So. Perry, Okla. (Perry HS)
90 Thomas Carroll DE 6-5 240 Jr. Lakewood, N.J. (Lakewood HS)
91 Joe Joseph DL 6-4 270 Fr. Orlando, Fla. (Oak Ridge HS)
92 Orien Harris DT 6-2 300 Jr. Newark, DE (Newark HS)
93 Dwayne Hendricks DE 6-3 250 Fr. Millville, N.J. (Millville HS)
94 Eric Moncur DE 6-3 260 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Carol City HS)
95 Bryan Pata DE 6-4 266 So. Miami, Fla. (Central HS)
96 Alton Wright DE 6-4 245 Sr. Houston, Texas (Kilgore JC)
97 Rhyan Anderson DL 6-5 265 Fr. Oak Creek, Wis. (Oak Creek HS)
98 Baraka Atkins DE 6-4 265 So. Sarasota, Fla. (Booker HS)
99 Kareem Brown DT 6-5 300 So. Miami, Fla. (Norland HS)

2014:

1 Artie Burns DB 6-0 198 So. Miami, Fla. (Miami Northwestern HS)
2 Deon Bush DB 6-1 203 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Columbus HS)
2 Joseph Yearby RB 5-9 180 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Central HS)
3 Stacy Coley WR 6-1 185 So. Pompano Beach, Fla. (Northeast HS)
3 Tracy Howard DB 5-11 184 Jr. Miramar, Fla. (Miramar HS)
4 Phillip Dorsett WR 5-10 185 Sr. Ft. Lauderdale, Fla. (St. Thomas Aquinas HS)
5 Standish Dobard TE 6-4 260 So. New Orleans, La. (Edna Karr HS)
5 Jermaine Grace LB 6-1 210 So. Miami Gardens, Fla. (Miramar HS)
6 Jamal Carter S 6-1 207 So. Homestead, Fla. (Miami Southridge HS)
6 Herb Waters WR 6-2 191 Jr. Homestead, Fla. (Homestead HS)
7 Gus Edwards RB 6-2 235 So. Staten Island, N.Y. (Tottenville HS)
7 Marques Gayot S 6-1 205 Fr. Lake Worth, Fla. (Park Vista Community HS)
8 Duke Johnson RB 5-9 206 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Norland HS)
9 Malcolm Lewis WR 6-0 193 RSo. Miramar, Fla. (Miramar HS)
9 Chad Thomas DE 6-5 255 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Booker T. Washington HS)
11 Ryan Williams QB 6-6 225 Sr. Pembroke Pines, Fla. (Memphis) (Miramar HS)
12 Malik Rosier QB 6-1 212 Fr. Mobile, Ala. (Faith Academy)
13 Gray Crow QB 6-3 224 So. Clearwater, Fla. (Countryside HS)
15 D'Mauri Jones WR 6-4 196 So. Leesburg, Fla. (Leesburg HS)
15 Brad Kaaya QB 6-4 218 Fr. West Hills, Calif. (Chaminade-Madonna College Prep)
16 Jake Heaps QB 6-1 210 Sr. Sammamish, Wash. (Skyline HS)
16 Justin Vogel P 6-4 218 So. Tampa, Fla. (Florida) (Berkeley Prep)
17 Isaac Hoza QB 6-3 175 RFr. Ft. Lauderdale, Fla. (Calvary Christian Academy)
17 Tyriq McCord LB 6-3 245 Jr. Tampa, Fla. (Jefferson HS)
18 Matt Goudis K 6-0 172 Jr. West Hills, Calif. (Chaminade-Madonna College Prep)
18 Michael Welch QB 6-3 218 RFr. Winnetka, Ill. (New Trier HS)
19 Kevin Olsen QB 6-3 210 RFr. Wayne, N.J. (Wayne Hills HS)
20 Ray Lewis III DB 5-9 190 RFr. Longwood, Fla. (Lake Mary Prep)
21 Antonio Crawford DB 5-11 191 Jr. Tampa, Fla. (H.B. Plant)
21 Josh Johnson WR 5-5 160 RFr. Jacksonville, Fla. (The Bolles School)
22 Kiy Hester DB 6-0 205 Fr. Wayne, N.J. (DePaul Catholic HS)
24 Michael Badgley K 5-10 180 Fr. Summit, N.J. (Fork Union Military Academy) (Summit Senior HS)
24 Stephen Sweeney WR 5-11 175 Jr. Ridgewood, N.J. (New Hampshire) (Don Bosco HS)
25 Dallas Crawford DB 5-10 195 Jr. Fort Myers, Fla. (South Fort Myers HS)
26 Rayshawn Jenkins DB 6-1 208 Jr. St. Petersburg, Fla. (Admiral Farragut Academy)
27 Ricky Carroll P 6-3 198 RSr. Mission Viejo, Calif. (Orange Coast College)
27 Ryan Mayes DB 6-1 185 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Northwestern HS)
28 Nantambu-Akil Fentress DB 5-9 193 Sr. Nashville, Tenn. (The Ensworth School)
29 Corn Elder DB 5-10 182 So. Nashville, Tenn. (The Ensworth School)
30 De'Andre Johnson RB 5-8 196 Sr. Miami, Fla. (Ellsworth CC) (Monsignor Pace HS)
31 Malik Mayweather WR 6-0 180 RFr. Olive Branch, Miss. (Olive Branch HS)
33 Trent Harris DE 6-2 242 Fr. Winter Park, Fla. (Winter Park HS)
34 Thurston Armbrister LB 6-3 235 Sr. Hollywood, Fla. (Hollywood Hills HS)
35 Nate Dortch DB 5-11 180 So. Fort Myers, Fla. (South Fort Myers HS)
36 Alex Figueroa LB 6-3 242 So. Stafford, Va. (Brooke Point HS)
37 Ladarius Gunter DB 6-2 198 Sr. Montgomery, Ala. (Jefferson Davis)
38 Joseph Rogers WR 6-2 228 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Sunset HS)
38 Jordan Tolson DB 6-1 195 Sr. Inglewood, Calif. (Harvard-Westlake School)
39 Ronald Regula FB 6-2 240 Sr. Miami, Fla. (Palmetto)
40 Grant Coffman P/K 5-8 182 RFr. Dublin, Ohio (Dublin Coffman HS)
41 Wyatt Chickillo DB 6-0 210 RFr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Palmetto HS)
43 Tyler Odems FB 6-0 240 So. Manassas, Va. (Dean JC) (Osbourn Park HS)
44 Demetrius Jackson DE 6-5 240 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Booker T. Washington HS)
44 Walter Tucker RB 6-0 218 So. Plantation, Fla. (American Heritage HS)
45 Isai Cetoute TE 6-3 245 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Krop HS)
45 Dominic Sicilian SS 5-10 180 So. Hebron, Ohio (Miami, Ohio) (Granville HS)
46 Clive Walford TE 6-4 263 Sr. Belle Glade, Fla. (Glades Central HS)
47 Raphael Akpejiori TE 6-9 241 Gr. Lagos, *****ia (Sunrise Christian Academy)
47 Ufomba Kamalu DL 6-6 285 RJr. Fayetteville, Ga. (Butler CC) (Starr's Mill HS)
48 Josh Bacon K 5-11 182 RFr. Melville, N.Y. (St. Anthony's HS)
48 Hugo Delapenha Jr. DB 5-11 190 RSr. Cape Coral, Fla. (Bishop Verot HS)
49 Aaron Martinez K/P 5-8 165 So. San Diego, Calif. (Barry University) (St. Augustine HS)
51 Juwon Young LB 6-2 240 Fr. Albany, Ga. (Albany HS)
52 Kc McDermott OL 6-6 314 Fr. Wellington, Fla. (Palm Beach Central HS)
52 Denzel Perryman LB 6-0 242 Sr. Coral Gables, Fla. (Coral Gables HS)
53 Jared Goldenberg LB 6-0 220 RFr. Ramsey, N.J. (Don Bosco HS)
54 JaWand Blue LB 6-0 232 So. Boca Raton, Fla. (West Boca Raton HS)
54 Hunter Knighton OL 6-6 295 RFr. Pottstown, Pa. (The Hun School of Princeton)
55 Frank Gabriel LS 6-3 215 Jr. Monmouth Beach, N.J. (Red Bank Catholic HS)
56 Raphael Kirby LB 6-1 235 Jr. Stone Mountain, Ga. (Stephenson HS)
57 Mike Smith DE 6-1 221 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Northwestern HS)
58 Darrion Owens LB 6-3 217 Fr. Orange Park, Fla. (Oakleaf HS)
62 Shane McDermott OL 6-4 296 Sr. Lake Worth, Fla. (Palm Beach Central HS)
63 Danny Isidora OL 6-4 316 So. Weston, Fla. (Cypress Bay HS)
64 Hunter Wells OL 6-6 312 Jr. Canton, Ill. (Canton HS)
66 Sunny Odogwu OL 6-8 324 RFr. Ezeagu, *****ia (Hargrave Military Academy)
67 Alex Gall OL 6-5 306 So. Mason, Ohio (Archbishop Moeller HS)
68 Nick Linder OL 6-3 285 Fr. Ft. Lauderdale, Fla. (St. Thomas Aquinas HS)
70 Jon Feliciano OL 6-5 320 Sr. Davie, Fla. (Western HS)
71 Anthony Chickillo DL 6-4 277 Sr. Tampa, Fla. (Alonso HS)
72 Earl Moore DL 6-1 304 Jr. Tampa, Fla. (Hillsborough HS)
73 Trevor Darling OL 6-5 320 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Central HS)
74 Ereck Flowers OL 6-6 322 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Norland HS)
75 Sean Harvey OL 6-4 290 Sr. Largo, Fla. (UCF) (Indian Rocks HS)
76 Taylor Gadbois OL 6-8 316 So. Dallas, Ga. (East Paulding HS)
80 Rashawn Scott WR 6-2 205 Sr. Melbourne, Fla. (Melbourne Central HS)
82 Tyre Brady WR 6-3 203 Fr. Homestead, Fla. (South Dade HS)
83 Braxton Berrios WR 5-9 185 Fr. Raleigh, N.C. (Leesville Road HS)
84 Greg Golden WR 6-3 195 RFr. Red Bank, N.J. (Red Bank Catholic HS)
85 Beau Sandland TE 6-6 255 Sr. Woodland Hills, Calif. (Pierce College) (Simi Valley HS)
87 Garrett Kidd WR 6-2 188 Jr. Midland, Mich. (Herbert Henry Dow HS)
88 Jake O'Donnell TE 6-7 255 So. Doylestown, Pa. (Central Bucks East HS)
90 Corey King DL 6-1 302 Jr. Boca Raton, Fla. (West Boca Raton HS)
91 Olsen Pierre DL 6-5 305 Sr. Rahway, N.J. (Fork Union Military Academy) (Rahway HS)
92 Courtel Jenkins DL 6-1 320 Fr. Wayne, N.J. (DePaul Catholic HS)
93 Calvin Heurtelou DL 6-3 310 Jr. Spring Valley, N.Y. (Scottsdale CC) (Spring Valley HS)
94 Anthony Naser DE 6-4 260 RJr. San Francisco, Calif. (City College of San Francisco) (Torrey Pines HS)
95 Anthony Moten DL 6-4 295 Fr. Ft. Lauderdale, Fla. (St. Thomas Aquinas HS)
97 Dwayne Hoilett DL 6-3 245 So. Vero Beach, Fla. (Vero Beach HS)
98 Al-Quadin Muhammad DE 6-4 242 So. Irvington, N.J. (Don Bosco HS)
99 Jelani Hamilton DL 6-5 290 Jr. Fort Lauderdale, Fla. (St. Thomas Aquinas HS)
 
Advertisement
2004 for sure 2014 roster doesn't have 10 1st rounders like 2004

wait until 2018 to make such comments because there is definitely 1st round talent on this roster and you have no idea how this incoming freshman class will develop
 
Advertisement
Better question after the season. Right now I don't think it's that close but 2014 can make some noise.
 
Advertisement
Qb.... I'd take Berlin over any Qb we have now.
Rb.... I'll take gore over duke(if any of u say Duke u are a prisoner of the moment)
Wr.... I'd take roscoe and Moss over any of our wrs now(Coley will be dope but still early) ****..... Even leggett balled that yr
Te...... Olson and everet easily
Ol....04 easily..... Winston and Myers?
Dl....... Hahahahahahhaha
Lbs....... Rocky, Beason and Leon over this group who only has Denzel who comes close to them
Dbs..... Antrel, Merriweather, Jennings and threat wins this..... And even Reddick balled that year too
Kicker...... We would take peattie all day now
Punter...... Lmao...... Who ever we put in uniform is a better option than Monroe
Kick returner..... No Point in answering this
 
Looking at first rounders alone doesn't tell the whole story…especially when you break it down by position group. Which group, as a whole, would you prefer?

2004:
4 Devin Hester WR 5-11 185 So. Riviera Beach (Suncoast HS)
8 Darnell Jenkins WR 5-10 185 So. Miami, Fla. (Central HS)
80 Akieem Jolla WR 6-4 190 Unk New Orleans, La. (St. Augustine HS)
87 Khalil Jones WR 6-2 210 Fr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Northwestern HS)
38 Rashaun Jones WR 6-1 180 Fr. Lake City, Fla. (Columbia High School- South)
9 Lance Leggett WR 6-3 180 Fr. Bartow, Fla. (Arlington (Texas) Grace Prep)
85 Ryan Moore WR 6-3 215 So. Orlando, Fla. (Dr. Phillips HS)
83 Sinorice Moss WR 5-8 180 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Carol City HS)
1 Roscoe Parrish WR 5-9 170 Jr. Miami, Fla. (Miami Senior HS)


2014:
83 Braxton Berrios WR 5-9 185 Fr. Raleigh, N.C. (Leesville Road HS)
82 Tyre Brady WR 6-3 203 Fr. Homestead, Fla. (South Dade HS)
3 Stacy Coley WR 6-1 185 So. Pompano Beach, Fla. (Northeast HS)
4 Phillip Dorsett WR 5-10 185 Sr. Ft. Lauderdale, Fla. (St. Thomas Aquinas HS)
15 D'Mauri Jones WR 6-4 196 So. Leesburg, Fla. (Leesburg HS)
9 Malcolm Lewis WR 6-0 193 RSo. Miramar, Fla. (Miramar HS)
80 Rashawn Scott WR 6-2 205 Sr. Melbourne, Fla. (Melbourne Central HS)
6 Herb Waters WR 6-2 191 Jr. Homestead, Fla. (Homestead HS)
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
2004 in a landslide as of now. a lot of the 2014 players that we are relying on are still young so too early and hard to tell.
 
2004 in a landslide as of now. a lot of the 2014 players that we are relying on are still young so too early and hard to tell.
The 2014 class will never surpass the 2004 class. Too many first rounders and NFL starters on that team. Talent wise you can't find another team in all of college football that can surpass that 2004 team.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top