Search results

I respect your opinion on everything - even if I see a different side of it. I only show the numbers for people to maybe rethink how much context/situation affected things. We all have the benefit of hindsight, and it's ok to rethink things. - Look at the numbers above - Were each RB's...

I think South Florida players are the best in the country. The trick is to get the right ones, which we haven't been doing for a while. At least not near enough of the right ones. But no question the fanbase will be more forgiving to a South Florida player than an out of state player. And...

I agree - ALL RB's the last 10+ years have been good college RB's - so I don't want to act like they're not. But there's distinctly different talent levels. Lumping them all together as "NFL Talents" isn't really fair. Our 3 Tiers for both College & NFL ability are: Tier 1 - NFL...

I'll never understand why Walton's 2017 was seen as him BEASTING instead of it just being par for the course? 2015 Joe Yearby (First 4 games) - 4.9 ypc at end of the year 58-424 yds - 7.3 ypc - 4 TD 2016 Mark Walton (First 4 games) - 5.3 ypc at end of the year 63-445 yds - 7.1 ypc - 8 TD 2017...

Yes, Richt chose Walton over Gus and Yearby. He would've chosen Walton over anyone no matter what. That's the point. Just look at the stats. I've asked you 6 questions below. I put your over/under at 2 for answering them. Going into 2016, here were their career stats: Yearby - 291-1,511...

No I understand what you're saying, and I think it's definitely a fair point. But how do you quantify that, you know? Like - would you say getting 5 carries in the 4th quarter vs an 8 win team in is more of an advantage than getting 5 carries in the 1st half vs a 2 win team? But your points...

Here's the % of Carries, Yds, TD's in their career at JUST MIAMI cam against Non-P5, P5, Top 25 teams: It's almost exactly the same - but you keep saying over and over how they're not. This isn't about winning or losing an argument - the numbers just are what they are. Also, when you say...

You were the first to make the Walton vs Gus straight up in 2017 - not me. But when I did, it shows Walton was still no better vs P5 than Gus. Which is my whole point. What I am comparing is their stats as a whole against P5 teams: Vs P5 Walton - 283-1,081 yds, 3.8 ypc, 11 TD's - Scored a TD...

Again - I'm fine if you think Walton is a better RB. I don't agree that Walton was MUCH better - and I don't agree with the lack of consistency in the arguments you're making. Walton vs Choc - You say I cherry pick stats, but then you say- "Go back and look at those game logs from 2015" -...

Walton played 22 games against Power 5 teams. He was good in 3. He was somewhere between ok and bad in 19. But the 3 out of 22 good games came in a row - so for some reason he's judged just on those 3 instead of all 22. The inability of the fanbase to see that Walton was an average RB who...

2 questions for you: Georgia Leading Rushers under Richt: Group 1 - Todd Gurley, Nick Chubb, Sony Michel, Knowshon Moreno, Isaiah Crowell Group 2 - Verron Haynes, Musa Smith, Michael Cooper, Kregg Lumpkin, Washaun Ealey, Thomas Brown (who started over Moreno) 1) Which group do you think Mark...

With the benefit of hindsight - a couple questions for you Do you think Walton was really good in college? Or looking back, do you think he was overrated? Like - do you think Walton was much better than Gus in college and definitely should have been a high draft choice? Or do you think...

That's totally fair - I just see it differently. Walton being better than Gus in college is the popular opinion. My opinion was always they're close but I prefer Gus. Yes, Walton missed 9 games due to injury in 3 years at Miami. Gus missed 20 games due to injury in his first 3 years. Yes...

Yup - Gus had all the advantages, while Walton had all the disadvantages. Sure. That's Walton Whining 101. Let me know when you'd like to take the Master Class.

You're right it isn't apples to apples - but again, not in the way that you think Vs Top 25 opponents: Walton - 71-220 yds, 3.1 ypc, 0 TD. Against 7 Top 25 teams, he never averaged over 3.5 ypc in any game Gus - 80-255 yds, 3.2 ypc, 1 TD. Against 8 Top 25 teams, he averaged over 4.0 ypc in...

Yeah - I mean, I get the South Florida and ranking bias - it makes sense. But it was taken to such an extreme with hating on Gus while simultaneously overhyping Yearby and later Walton to a point that never made sense if you just watched them play.

Again, it's a perception vs reality thing. This isn't aimed at you DTP - I'm just looking at how the narratives sometimes don't match the reality. Narrative - Walton has a nose for the end zone was great in short yardage, and Gus was terrible. Reality - Gus was as good or better in those...

Safe to say Richt used Gus in very weird ways. Examples: Blowouts vs FAMU, FAU, App St: Walton - 48 carries Yearby - 35 carries Gus - 11 carries FAU - Yearby had 20 carries, Walton 16, Gus 0 in a 20 pt blowout. Why? Why so many carries for your lead RB and so little for the backup in...

I agree Gus was a an average RB and didn't do anything to indicate he'd be a "special talent" in the NFL. - But Gus was the same level of talent as Walton/Yearby/Martin - and you're saying all 3 were better than Gus. - You're saying Gus underachieved in college, but given he was the #681...

- Martin had a 5.2 ypc at Rutgers & Gus had a 5.3 ypc at Miami (before Gus transferred). - Martin had a 4.5 ypc at Rutgers & Gus had a 4.3 ypc at Rutgers (when they were on the same team). It looks very similar to me. If you're going to say - Martin's 5.2 ypc at Rutgers was better than Gus's...