Search results

You're missing the whole boat. You're jumping in way late in debate over several posts. The ratings aren't an exact science or any science for that matter. In some years 2/3 5-stars haven't even panned out to be starters let alone best in the country. It's about evaluations not stars. Yes...

Didn't win a natty as a starter.

Maybe he's he's just now developing and catching up to his peers. A lot of CIS think that once you get your star rating then that's what you are and all you will ever be. All of the recruits have an entire year to improve before suiting up for their first college game. With Williams earning...

The fact that he's there puts him in the top 20 of QBs. This kid flew under the radar and is now emerging. I see his 3-star as the floor. I really don't care what he gets rated as long as he goes out and proves he belongs with the top QB prospects.

That's fair enough. The only reason to bring the NFL into the picture is because the 5-star prospect is the one designated to be a future 1st round NFL QB. That's why there's a max of 32 5-stars to correspond to the 32 NFL 1st round draft positions. So, the point was to show that not all...

Yes, it does. I'm only looking at All-American QBs and what we're their ranking. 12 All-American QBs. 4 of them were 5-stars. The 5-star is supposed to be the can't miss 1st round draft pick. They should be an All-American every year. They're not.

You're percentages don't make sense and are skewed for the very reason you say you need to use them. There are 32 5-star players every year. The 5-star is to represent the players projected to be 1st round draft picks. These are supposed to be the "can't miss" guys. The fact that there's only...

People popping all that **** about 5-star QBs and championships that I just disproved. What matters is the quality of the player, not some star a recruiting website assigns to a player. Are any of those guys even qualified to evaluate QBs? It just kills me listening to recruiting media that...

Did UGA win with a 5-star QB? There were 4 5-star QBs that won a national championship in the 12 years of BCS era. Vince Young 2005 Chris Leak 2006 Tim Tebow 2008 Cam Newton 2010 There were only 2 5-star QBs that won a national championship in the 11 years of the CFP era. Jameis Winston...

Junior season. A whole year to get better. STFU!!!! Stop putting math in there you don't even have. It doesn't make you look smarter. "He's OK." Like you have evaluated him.

Nah fella. Nothing wrong with my reading comp. You made a blanket statement on statistics with no factual reference. You didn't even quote the 3-stars which would be inaccurate at this point. It's this mentality of CIS that drives me crazy. People putting kids in boxes based on ratings...

What raw data? The young man hasn't even played his senior season of high school which is my point. You're trying to make a blank statistical reference based on recruiting service evaluations from his junior year. He's now going to the Elite 11 finals. Update your fake stats. A better...

Your statement is flawed. A probability based on what? His star rating?

That's all you got. Thought so.

Why wouldn't he see a P5 field? Because some 3-star rating is attached to his forehead? There are more former 3-star QB's that are in the current top 20 of starting NFL QB's (11). Those star labels don't mean **** unless you're #1 or #2 at your position. He's going to compete at the Elite 11...

That was not my intention. A lot of CIS get all worked up over any 5-star. I was just pointing out that a 5-star QB doesn't guarantee success and people should temper their expectations. Any QB (any player for that matter) needs to be developed at the college level. It's up the individual to...

You're just enventing things I didn't even say. Who cares about QB play 20 years ago? Your not even on the same topic as what I said. I pointed to Clemson in the past 5 years getting 5-star QBs that haven't panned out. It wasn't about just any QB production. It's about the 5-star QBs which...

If Gattis is here only 2 years, then leaves for a HC job, Moore would be a Rsh freshman. If he stayed, he'd have to sit one more year behind Garcia. Then he'd have to compete the following year for the starting QB job under an OC that didn't recruit him. I just don't think any of the 5-star...

I agree with you. The thing is you could be a team that loads up on 5-star QBs every year. If a QB starts at leat 2 years, you'd have 5-stsr QBs sitting 2-4 years to play. That is not going to happen. A 5-star kid, let alone a QB, isn't going to sit for more than 1 year. They're going to...

The 5th star is given to those who are future NFL 1st round players. If they didn't get drafted high, they likely didn't have a good college career. There are usually 3-4 5-star high school QBs every year. Not all of them pan out to be great.