Arm strength is important... height and athletisicm matter... but the dudes that are football nerds own the QB position. Brees, Manning, Brady... nerds, even in college we have example of Dorsey, Moore & McElroy... Nerd QBs with high character. So all I want to know is... is N'kosi a nerd? Does...
Since '05 I think your list is solid, I would make a couple of changes though...
WR: Ahmmon Richards & Jeff Thomas are better than those guys IMO.
TE: Herndon > Epps
DL: Campbell, Bailey, Willis, Jackson
CB: Elder & Burns deserve some consideration
K2's stats, and really that '03 season was the start of the fall... Coker was showing true colors there. We still havent got back to that level of talent, although last year's D wad the closest so far imo. But that '03 D was something.... Taylor, Vince, Vilma, Rolle, DJ and a bunch of other...
I'm wondering who the best players are that you watched with your own eyes, no players you didnt see. Ive been a fan since 2000 when I was 16. Here's my team.
QB #11 Ken Dorsey
RB #2 Willis McGahee
WR #5 Andre Johnson
WR #87 Reggie Wayne
WR #6 Santana Moss
TE #88 Jeremy Shockey
LT #78 Bryant...